Forum Discussion

Leda's avatar
Leda
Explorer
May 22, 2018

Atwood G6A7E water heater tank replacement advice needed

Hi there!

Our water heater tank cracked during winter - long story short - it seems that emptying the tank of our European class C and the American Class A (Damon Challenger 1996) is actually different... anyway now we need to replace it. I am not having much luck finding an used one on craigslist so I ask for your advice in any of the following possibilities:

- if someone knows any places (junk yards) I could buy a used one around Vancouver - please, do tell

- the new one is about 700C$ on amazon, 900C$ in the RV shops - and I am not sure if it is actually my model... one says they have only tank, the other says my model does not have the tank sold separately, third one says my model has been replaced with another model G6A8AE... etc. Which makes me feel really uncertain what to do and who to trust. Not mentioning that they want to replace it and they don't have appointments available for months

- I am reading online for tankless water heaters - found Gerard 2GWHAM - price is almost same as the atwood with the tank - has very controversial reviews... some say it is the best purchase ever, some say it does not work and you can't return it.. maybe there are more reliable brands and models which are tested in the forum you could recommend...

We are really confused what to do here - we are looking for the quickest cost efficient solution as we have 2 kids under 5 and not having hot water makes our life quite harder and our vacations not that pleasant :))

I appreciate any advice on the matter. What would you do? Thank you! We really appreciate it.
  • Leda, ship to a mail drop in Blaine or Point Roberts. That shipping quote to Vancouver will include Brokerage fees. Good Luck, Don
  • Thanks for the answers! :))

    140$ is amazing price for the tank itself but unfortunately they want 75$ shipping to Canada soooo it comes to 300C$ which is the price I found at a RV repair place... the thing is that the guys there tell me to get the whole unit replaced (whole water heater is 660C$) as the 300$ savings will go into labor cost as replacing the tank only takes more time and sometimes it doesn't really goes smooth... also there will be no warranty if replacing just a part... so I am thinking of getting this done...

    The Gerrard tankless water heater will cost me about the same price maybe 100$ more but reviews are 50/50 and the other 50 really hate it...

    On craigslist I couldn't find something cheaper soooo finally I don't have much of a choice I guess...

    Thanks for the answers once again :))
  • Leda wrote:
    Hi there!

    Our water heater tank cracked during winter - long story short - it seems that emptying the tank of our European class C and the American Class A (Damon Challenger 1996) is actually different... anyway now we need to replace it. I am not having much luck finding an used one on craigslist so I ask for your advice in any of the following possibilities:

    - if someone knows any places (junk yards) I could buy a used one around Vancouver - please, do tell

    - the new one is about 700C$ on amazon, 900C$ in the RV shops - and I am not sure if it is actually my model... one says they have only tank, the other says my model does not have the tank sold separately, third one says my model has been replaced with another model G6A8AE... etc. Which makes me feel really uncertain what to do and who to trust. Not mentioning that they want to replace it and they don't have appointments available for months

    - I am reading online for tankless water heaters - found Gerard 2GWHAM - price is almost same as the atwood with the tank - has very controversial reviews... some say it is the best purchase ever, some say it does not work and you can't return it.. maybe there are more reliable brands and models which are tested in the forum you could recommend...

    We are really confused what to do here - we are looking for the quickest cost efficient solution as we have 2 kids under 5 and not having hot water makes our life quite harder and our vacations not that pleasant :))

    I appreciate any advice on the matter. What would you do? Thank you! We really appreciate it.

    check on kijji there is a place around Brantford
  • I can't help you as far as availability in Canada.......

    BUT the replacement tank is readily available new.

    Atwood 91641 is the part number for replacement tank
    Fits the following models:
    G6A-4E, G6A-6E, G6A-7E, G6A-8E, G9-EXT

    On Sale at Adventure RV for $147 US.....S/H??
    Tank, insulating jacket and seal ring/gasket set

    You have to remove all components from old tank, cut off/remove seal rings on combustion chamber port and exhaust port and separate tank from metal drawn pan.


    RV Salvage by state & Canada