A proper Winegard (either the latest version or the earlier version with WingMan add-on) with good connections to a working power plate, will defeat all comers when it comes to deep fringe reception.
Thing to remember here is that the "old VHF" (channels 2 - 13) may display with those numbers but they're now assigned to UHF channels (14 and up). This is why we need WingMan or a late model antenna that's optimized for UHF.
An old Winegard with WingMan works well, but a newer one with WingMan integrated with it works still better. WingMan is a $29 part and a complete new head, WingMan and all, is only $43. Makes sense to simply replace the head and get the latest capability.
And yes, they're all Digital. HD and all.