Hi guysBeen lurking here for a while sucking up all the info I can. My wife and I are ready to pull the trigger and buy out first 5th wheel. One of local dealers has been in business for 50 years here, family owned and very easy going and friendly. No pressures at all. So we have narrowed our choices to 2 units. I live in Vegas but I work in the oil fields of west Texas and east NM. I work 4 weeks on and 2 off. My wife and I will be living in the RV for the 4 weeks at a time, then driving back to Vegas on our off time. We own a home in Vegas. Out 2 choices came down to one 2014 and one 2011. The new model is the Heartland Elkridge 32TSRE, 'priced to move' at right at 45k. The used model is the 2011 Forest River Cardinal 3150RL. Priced at 44k, already reduced to 'under 40k' in initial conversations. My wife likes the idea of new and the accompanying warranty. I like the looks of the cardinal. Lots of upgrades over the Elkridge, seems to be a higher end model. Lots of little bells and whistles she doesn't really notice or care about. Biggest selling point for me is probably the insulation and heated tanks. Just like the idea of good weatherproofing. With this sparse information, can you guys make any recommendations? The dealer offers 1 year warranty on the new, 30 days gaurantee on the appliances on the used model. I suppose I can get an extended warranty on the used, but not sure they are worthwhile or cost effective. Thank you for your attention and I look forward to your responses,Michael

"If the wife ain't happy nobody is." Apart from making her happy, the depreciation on a new unit is considerably greater than a pre-owned one. If value and depreciation are important to you I would look at pre-owned. If new is important go in understanding how much depreciation you will suffer in the first five years. Most RV's are worth about half in five years from their new price.

I think you will find the Cardinal the better choice. And the support you can get from Forest River is second to none.

donn0128 wrote:I think you will find the Cardinal the better choice. ......Agree with the Cardinal which is upper level in the Forest River line up but a very nice upper midlevel in overall market. I'm betting better insulation and many additional features.The Elkridge is in the upper entry level class. I went to NADA and did not add any options and got this Result. End of the day you need to be very comfortable with your choice as you will spend a lot of time in the unit. Randu

Choose what the wife wants otherwise if anything goes wrong with the Cardinal you'll hear it from her for the rest of your life. However, if you choose the Elkridge and something goes wrong you'll still hear it from her for the rest of your life...."Why didn't you try harder to convince me to go with the Cardinal ?"...

We got a used higher end (Carriage) 5th wheel when we retired. It was the right decision for us because it was 2 years old and had all the bugs worked out but was still in great shape. Higher quality will pay off if you are in it for a month at a time.Brian

Brand new, need advice on buying new vs used | Good Sam Community

jmtandem
Explorer II
Jun 19, 2014
"If the wife ain't happy nobody is."

Apart from making her happy, the depreciation on a new unit is considerably greater than a pre-owned one. If value and depreciation are important to you I would look at pre-owned. If new is important go in understanding how much depreciation you will suffer in the first five years. Most RV's are worth about half in five years from their new price.
donn0128
Explorer II
Jun 19, 2014
I think you will find the Cardinal the better choice. And the support you can get from Forest River is second to none.
Randu
Explorer
Jun 19, 2014
donn0128 wrote:
I think you will find the Cardinal the better choice. ......

Agree with the Cardinal which is upper level in the Forest River line up but a very nice upper midlevel in overall market. I'm betting better insulation and many additional features.

The Elkridge is in the upper entry level class.

I went to NADA and did not add any options and got this Result.

End of the day you need to be very comfortable with your choice as you will spend a lot of time in the unit. Randu
the_bear_II
Explorer
Jun 19, 2014
Choose what the wife wants otherwise if anything goes wrong with the Cardinal you'll hear it from her for the rest of your life.

However, if you choose the Elkridge and something goes wrong you'll still hear it from her for the rest of your life...."Why didn't you try harder to convince me to go with the Cardinal ?"...
samandtheduck
Explorer
Jun 19, 2014
We got a used higher end (Carriage) 5th wheel when we retired. It was the right decision for us because it was 2 years old and had all the bugs worked out but was still in great shape. Higher quality will pay off if you are in it for a month at a time.
Brian
dbbls
Explorer
Jun 19, 2014
I have bought two used and two new 5th wheels. Not a problem with the two used, both new ones were lemons. It takes a few years to get all the problems fixed. I would go with the Cardinal without a doubt.
Dynalmadman
Explorer
Jun 19, 2014
Thanks guys.

Yah, I knew very quickly that the Cardinal was the nicer choice. I guess I should have titled the thread 'How to convince that wife that the used one is better than the new one'.

Heh heh

Michael
old_guy
Explorer
Jun 19, 2014
I don't know about forest river being second to one for customer service. I know I will never buy another forest river product mainly because of their customer support
donn0128
Explorer II
Jun 19, 2014
And yet on any of the Forest River forums customer service is about the bottom in complaints. My cedar creek has been fantastic and their customer service has been fantastic
Grit_dog
Navigator
Jun 20, 2014
While I have only owned one used camper, have friends that buy new RVs every few years it seems.
1 year warranty is not very long and IMO mostly fixes the bugs and defects from the factory. After that is taken care of they are pretty reliable and the warranty is gone anyways.

With the prices being very similar buy the one that best suits you.
Only justification I could see for new over used is that the new one spent 3 less years out cooking in the sun and will not oxidize and deteriorate as quickly.