Need new water heater question

RJsfishin,

I'm guessing that what houstonstroker might be getting at is that it might be the Temperature & Pressure Relief Valve which might be leaking, but presenting as if it's a leak in the tank itself. Or possibly one of the other fittings on the tank. Just guessing. :)

~Rick

houstonstroker wrote:
Can you tell where the leak is coming from?

Coulda swore he said from the tank. Where on the tank ?? Like that mite make a difference ?

tewitt1949 wrote:
Thanks all, I agree it old and get new. Cost isn't and issue. The gas part has worked flawlessly. Since its passed the test of time, that part must be a good one. To be honest, many older things were made better than some new designed things.

I'll just order a new one. Amazon has replacements, with next day delivery.

Well, if it was me, I would also feel like the parts that ARE working are probably much better than what you're likely going to buy today, at least from a longevity perspective. But seeing as options are limited, I'd buy the complete replacement and install it. Then, in my spare time, I'd see if there was any way to repair/replace the original tank in a reasonable and economical manner. If so, I'd probably do it and then keep the entire assembly as a spare.

Two things are nearly certain: If you have a spare, you will not need it, and you'll never have to deal with this issue again. If you don't have a spare, your new water heater assembly will peter out right after the warranty is over. LOL

Good Luck,

~Rick

Mine is atwood. but YES. I just replaced the tank not the rest of it.

Now on my Atwood the tank came with new mounting hardware and a new element and relay I swapped the element (Since I had it out) with a 1500 Watt 240 volt (375 watts at 120 volt) element so that it heats slower. but trips the park? 30 amp breakers less often when I am on 30 amps. (Very nice when it is raining out).

Works great.

Can you tell where the leak is coming from?

Thanks all, I agree it old and get new. Cost isn't and issue. The gas part has worked flawlessly. Since its passed the test of time, that part must be a good one. To be honest, many older things were made better than some new designed things.

I'll just order a new one. Amazon has replacements, with next day delivery.

Jim-Linda wrote:
Don't really understand what you are asking... water heater comes with both electric and propane systems included. Use your existing electric hookup, the included 12v will take care of the propane.

What can't you understand? His tank is leaking, but the gas and electric part of the water heater works. He asked can he just buy a new tank instead of a whoe new water heater. Seems simple to me.

Old-Biscuit wrote:
NO.......can't replace tank on Suburban

23 yrs old.....time for a NEW whole complete water heater
IF old one is a 6 gal----new Suburban gas/electric 6 gal will fit opening
If old one is a 10 gal---new Suburban gas/electric 10 gal will fit opening

Swapping 6 for 10 would require changing opening
Swapping Suburban for Atwood....changing opening

But it's time for new one. You got 23 yrs out of the old one.

+1 on that one - put some gravy on it and call it a day!

NO.......can't replace tank on Suburban

23 yrs old.....time for a NEW whole complete water heater
IF old one is a 6 gal----new Suburban gas/electric 6 gal will fit opening
If old one is a 10 gal---new Suburban gas/electric 10 gal will fit opening

Swapping 6 for 10 would require changing opening
Swapping Suburban for Atwood....changing opening

But it's time for new one. You got 23 yrs out of the old one.

Not worth trying to replace tank on either Suburban or Atwood, if available.
Newer water heaters are more efficient. New assembly requires about the same effort to replace as tank alone.