1 Ton SRW Challenge

[Travlingman]

Pickuptrucks.com did a challenge of the one ton SRW's. Just started posting some of the results, Chevy won. One Ton Challenge

[Mortimer_Brewst]

Ralph Cramden wrote:

ScottG wrote:

BB_TX wrote:
More "news", based on personal opinions of a few "experts", for the sole purpose of selling magazines. Little to do with ownership satisfaction of any of the three.

And anyone in the world of statistic will tell you a sample of one is worthless.

hallelujah......Pickuptrucks.com LOL.


Did someone mention Betty White in this thread? What in the hell brand of truck is she driving? And what does she know anyway, she's a washed up hag? There are better Betty's in this world, Crocker and Rubble come to mind.

Taking cheap shots at a 96 year old woman? Real classy! :R

[ShinerBock]

IdaD wrote:

ShinerBock wrote:
Look, we all know that you like to think that whatever you have is the best thing in the world and it has no flaws. Sorry to tel you this but the Aisin has its flaws just like the Cummins we both drive.

Some people have a hard time with this concept. All three diesels are bada$$ trucks right now. They all do certain things better than the other two, but they all also have areas where the other two are superior. Admitting that shouldn't be a problem, just pick the truck with the pluses you really want and the minuses you can live with and be happy with it.

Exactly! They all have their pluses and minuses. What may make one good in one area may also make it worse in another. Nothing is perfect all the way around. What matters is that the truck you choose is best in the areas that are most important to you and not worry about the areas it is not good in because you did not buy it for those reasons.

[4x4ord]

Ive been experiencing my 5ver kind of pushing my truck around. It doesnt happen with the tandem dually gooseneck ... just the holiday trailer so I thought it was the trailer. Maybe I need to get rid of the Ford and get a Ram.

[IdaD]

ShinerBock wrote:
Look, we all know that you like to think that whatever you have is the best thing in the world and it has no flaws. Sorry to tel you this but the Aisin has its flaws just like the Cummins we both drive.

Some people have a hard time with this concept. All three diesels are bada$$ trucks right now. They all do certain things better than the other two, but they all also have areas where the other two are superior. Admitting that shouldn't be a problem, just pick the truck with the pluses you really want and the minuses you can live with and be happy with it.

[Grit_dog]

Threebigfords wrote:

SidecarFlip wrote:

RTCastillo wrote:

SidecarFlip wrote:
I only had to read the first line... Price. No truck today is worth 70 grand to me. Especially when you can buy a low mileage off lease vehicle with a factory warranty for about half of what a new one cost. I believe in letting the first owner/leasee take the depreciation hit. I'm not proud. Bought my last 2 vehicles that way.

One quick observations I've seen so far. Some RVers are over-truck for their trailer. Not my business really. And then again, they must have been able to afford it: the truck, higher maintenance and gas.

Almost tempted myself as first time RVer.

Oddly, I see a lot that are 'under trucked'. Wife and I stopped at Arby's on the way home and 2 large, I mean LARGE pull behind's were in the side parking lot, both being hitched to Ford 150's. Even said to the wife it looks as though the 'tail is wagging the dog'. I've always had a 1 ton pickup but I use mine for more than RV'ing. It's a farm truck too.

And I bet those F150's you were mocking have the same if not higher tow rating as your antique 1 ton truck.

Noooooo!
His antique truck is the holy grail of all that is and all that could ever bee in a pickup truck.......just ask him.

[spoon059]

alexleblanc wrote:
in the end they are all so well matched that arguing small differences in overall great performances seems like a waste of time.

AMEN!

It doesn't seem like a waste of time... it IS a waste of time. All 3 are great, all 3 are capable and all 3 offer slightly different options. If only I could afford one of them!!! Anyone wanna go halfsies?

[alexleblanc]

in the end they are all so well matched that arguing small differences in overall great performances seems like a waste of time.

I'm extremely happy with my truck, but to be honest I think if I switched to a GM or Ram tomorrow equipped similarly and the local dealer support was as good as the Ford one has been for me, I would be a happy camper and I doubt I would complain about the performance - lets be honest, we're all out there doing our favorite thing in the world and that's hauling our RV's to go on vacation or chase down adventure!

[ShinerBock]

Cummins12V98 wrote:
UH I did own a FULLY built DDT trans that my Son has now so I know what I am talking about. But hey you need to tune everything to get it the way yo want. I have Zero reason to do so.

That is not true. I probably would not tune the shifting on an Allison. The factory shift strategy is pretty spot on. Although the 6R140 is a stout trans, I would probably still tune its shift strategy to my liking. What can I say, I liked things tuned to my preferences and not generic to everyone else.

Look, we all know that you like to think that whatever you have is the best thing in the world and it has no flaws. Sorry to tel you this but the Aisin has its flaws just like the Cummins we both drive.

It is kind of ironic the PUTC and TFL both say the same things I have been saying about the Aisin in this forum. No need to bury your head in the sand and pretend it does not have any issues. It is just a slow shifting trans that tends to put you in the wrong gear for the situation at times. It is what it is.

[john_bet]

SidecarFlip wrote:
I only had to read the first line... Price. No truck today is worth 70 grand to me. Especially when you can buy a low mileage off lease vehicle with a factory warranty for about half of what a new one cost. I believe in letting the first owner/leasee take the depreciation hit. I'm not proud. Bought my last 2 vehicles that way.

Just where do you find 2 year old heavy duty 1 ton SRW CC LB with auto and a Laramie, Lariet, LXT package that are just off of a lease?

[Ralph_Cramden]

ScottG wrote:

BB_TX wrote:
More "news", based on personal opinions of a few "experts", for the sole purpose of selling magazines. Little to do with ownership satisfaction of any of the three.

And anyone in the world of statistic will tell you a sample of one is worthless.

hallelujah......Pickuptrucks.com LOL.


Did someone mention Betty White in this thread? What in the hell brand of truck is she driving? And what does she know anyway, she's a washed up hag? There are better Betty's in this world, Crocker and Rubble come to mind.

[valhalla360]

In terms of over/under trucked, these tests tell us little.

It's nothing special to have a 1/2 ton with 350hp that would blow away the top diesel dually of 20-25yrs ago in terms of pulling power and acceleration. All newer trucks are just crazy powerful in relation to a short while back.

It's usually the suspension capability that differentiates if you are over/under trucked for towing not the drive train.

[Threebigfords]

SidecarFlip wrote:

RTCastillo wrote:

SidecarFlip wrote:
I only had to read the first line... Price. No truck today is worth 70 grand to me. Especially when you can buy a low mileage off lease vehicle with a factory warranty for about half of what a new one cost. I believe in letting the first owner/leasee take the depreciation hit. I'm not proud. Bought my last 2 vehicles that way.

One quick observations I've seen so far. Some RVers are over-truck for their trailer. Not my business really. And then again, they must have been able to afford it: the truck, higher maintenance and gas.

Almost tempted myself as first time RVer.

Oddly, I see a lot that are 'under trucked'. Wife and I stopped at Arby's on the way home and 2 large, I mean LARGE pull behind's were in the side parking lot, both being hitched to Ford 150's. Even said to the wife it looks as though the 'tail is wagging the dog'. I've always had a 1 ton pickup but I use mine for more than RV'ing. It's a farm truck too.

And I bet those F150's you were mocking have the same if not higher tow rating as your antique 1 ton truck.

[Cummins12V98]

UH I did own a FULLY built DDT trans that my Son has now so I know what I am talking about. But hey you need to tune everything to get it the way yo want. I have Zero reason to do so.

[Me_Again]

ShinerBock wrote:
If you can't get $12-16k off on a new loaded Ram HD diesel, then you are probably doing something wrong or at the wrong dealer. Everyone I know has been able to get that much off.

Received this today.

"It's the end of the month and your wait has paid off! Hurry in and get your Ram truck while the selection is good. We need to sell 12 Rams before the close of business tomorrow!!!

Rebates and discounts have never been this high, in fact you can save over $14,000 off select 2018 Ram trucks. Please contact me via cell at 480.223.2094 or reply to this email to set up a convenient time to drop by and take home the truck of your dreams.
Thanks in advance,
Nick Covert
Sales Manager
Earnhardt CJDR
480.223.2094 (cell)
480.926.4000"

[Me_Again]

Interestingly the RAM score highest by the options of three judges, however lower on the statistical parts of the test. They did not clearly state why they rated it highest.