Forum Discussion

btcruzer's avatar
btcruzer
Explorer
Nov 23, 2014

bright enough?

I haven't read much about LED lighting lately but I just traded RVs and need to convert the lighting again. Previously, I'd used the bright ( or maybe "pure") white 48 5050 smds. I was pleased with them and didn't find them to be too bright. But my fixtures used a thick milkglass type lens so that might have cut down the light some. Now, my fixtures have the 1156 type bubs and typical RV style thin plastic lens. and I've found package deals for 48 3528 smd panels in warm white with 1156 base adapters. I'm needing at least 20 of these and want to keep it simple so I want the 1156 adapters. My question is " are people liking the warm white lighting and is the 3528 type bright enough?
  • Gdetrailer wrote:
    tenbear wrote:
    In my experience I have found the 3528 LEDs are about half as bright as the 5050s, I also like the warm white. I have also found a big difference in venders on eBay. Whatever you decide on, buy 1 or 2 and try them before buying a whole bunch.


    5050 LEDs although better than 3528 LEDs are not all that efficient.

    5050 LEDs are .22W each and only give off about 10-15 lumens per chip.

    on the other hand there are much more efficient LEDs, if you can find modules which use 5730 LEDs you will be much better off.

    5730 LEDs are 1/2W each and can net you about 100-120 lumens per watt.

    Basically 6 of the 5730s can give you more light than 48 of the 5050 LEDs..

    Color, well that is up to you but LEDs really vary drastically in the color aspect.. 3000K to 4000K will get you pretty close to incadescent and 5000K-6500K is going to get you the harsher blue/white color..


    Seems like you know what your talking about. I'm trying to replace the halogen bulbs in the puck style ceiling fixtures of my RV. I've tried various LEDs and had problems they seemed darker (less light) or harsh color. The fixtures use a G4 2 pin mount on the side. I need a pancake array. From you quote it appear I should buy:
    1. Get an array of at least 6 LEDs 5730 type.
    2. The 5730's should have a color temperature around 3000K to 4000K to get incandescent light color that is not too harsh.

    Do you have a suggestion on purchasing source?
  • Too many numbers ! I have now installed panels with 48 3528 leds. Warm white. got them because of the 1156 adapters and ease of install. BUT I also have some with 9 5630 LEDs but g4 type bases.

    how does the 5630s compare to the 5730s for current draw and light output?

    By the way, I much prefer the 3528s to the old 1156 bulbs and I'm sure the current draw is much lower. I'd asked my wife to reorder more LEDS, she checked her recent purchases on EBAY and ordered. Wrong, Im getting more 5630s--- so I guess I'll find a way to convert them to 1156 bases.... I should have plenty of light -- so all is good.

About DIY Maintenance

RV projects you can tackle on your own with a few friendly pointers.4,351 PostsLatest Activity: Jan 18, 2025