Forum Discussion

Tony_Slee's avatar
Tony_Slee
Explorer
Jun 26, 2013

Lippert Components

I have a Razor toy hauler made by Heartland and the ramp door was made by Lippert. The door has deteriorate at the top of the hinges. The design of this door is inadequate for the weight of the door. The plywood and Styrofoam has no integrity at the hinge support area. Neither Heartland or Lippert would help me in a replacement as the warranty had expired on the unit. This is a design failure not neglect on my part. FYI to anyone looking at toy haulers, beware of any ramps made by Lippert Components.
  • I seriously doubt that the entire ramp was made by Lippert. The frame, yes, but not the whole door. So IMHO your beef is with the way the ramp was constructed by Heartland. What do you load and how often?
  • I have a Razor toy hauler made by Heartland and the ramp door was made by Lippert. The door has deteriorate at the top of the hinges. The design of this door is inadequate for the weight of the door. The plywood and Styrofoam has no integrity at the hinge support area. Neither Heartland or Lippert would help me in a replacement as the warranty had expired on the unit. This is a design failure not neglect on my part. FYI to anyone looking at toy haulers, beware of any ramps made by Lippert Components.


    Tony,

    Here we go again with Lippert. Lippert only makes frames to the specifications of the coach manufacturer. I doubt it is a Lippert issue; it is much more likely a coach manufacturer issue. Look to Heartland and yours is likely not the only one with the poor design.
  • jmtandem wrote:
    I have a Razor toy hauler made by Heartland and the ramp door was made by Lippert. The door has deteriorate at the top of the hinges. The design of this door is inadequate for the weight of the door. The plywood and Styrofoam has no integrity at the hinge support area. Neither Heartland or Lippert would help me in a replacement as the warranty had expired on the unit. This is a design failure not neglect on my part. FYI to anyone looking at toy haulers, beware of any ramps made by Lippert Components.


    Tony,

    Here we go again with Lippert. Lippert only makes frames to the specifications of the coach manufacturer. I doubt it is a Lippert issue; it is much more likely a coach manufacturer issue. Look to Heartland and yours is likely not the only one with the poor design.


    If you were a manufacturer like Lippert and someone came to you with a design that you knew wouldn't work, wouldn't you be just as responsible for failure of said part?

    I know if it were me I wouldn't want to ruin my reputation by getting involved with it.
  • What year is your hauler. Theres been alot of ramp failures on here and also on the Heartland (Cyclone) forum. They are a pretty poor design, basically frameless with a cheap screwed together aluminum extrusion wrapped around the outer edge. I believe they did upgrade somewhere around 2010 or 2011.
  • If you were a manufacturer like Lippert and someone came to you with a design that you knew wouldn't work, wouldn't you be just as responsible for failure of said part?

    I know if it were me I wouldn't want to ruin my reputation by getting involved with it.
  • jmtandem wrote:
    If you were a manufacturer like Lippert and someone came to you with a design that you knew wouldn't work, wouldn't you be just as responsible for failure of said part?

    I know if it were me I wouldn't want to ruin my reputation by getting involved with it.


    Probably. But, I am not Lippert nor Heartland and to that end they did what they did. Maybe Lippert, that makes about 75 percent of all RV fifth wheel and travel trailer frames, did ask about the design. You and I don't know that. But at the end of the day they build what was ordered.


    But they did build it and thats good enough for me. When I go looking for a unit, it wont be one with Lippert crappy frames . Nor will it be one with China bomb tires or the Ford 6.0 engine. Enough bad things happen without going out and looking for trouble. JMO
  • powderman426 wrote:
    jmtandem wrote:
    If you were a manufacturer like Lippert and someone came to you with a design that you knew wouldn't work, wouldn't you be just as responsible for failure of said part?

    I know if it were me I wouldn't want to ruin my reputation by getting involved with it.


    Probably. But, I am not Lippert nor Heartland and to that end they did what they did. Maybe Lippert, that makes about 75 percent of all RV fifth wheel and travel trailer frames, did ask about the design. You and I don't know that. But at the end of the day they build what was ordered.


    But they did build it and thats good enough for me. When I go looking for a unit, it wont be one with Lippert crappy frames . Nor will it be one with China bomb tires or the Ford 6.0 engine. Enough bad things happen without going out and looking for trouble. JMO


    I'd buy a 6.0 over the 6.4 powerstroke any day of the week. Like clock work they will cost you a bunch of money around the 100K mark, if they make it.
  • But they did build it and thats good enough for me. When I go looking for a unit, it wont be one with Lippert crappy frames . Nor will it be one with China bomb tires or the Ford 6.0 engine. Enough bad things happen without going out and looking for trouble. JMO

  • not that this helps but Eclipse (Attitude) toyhauler that I had used a Lippert frame but made their own ramp gates in house do to quality control issues at whoever used to supply the ramp gates.

    Interesting watching how a ramp gate is made and surprised at how well they hold up considering how they are made.

    _
  • I had my ramp door replaced under warranty because it started to crease in the middle. I was told that the new one used "a new manufacturing process". No creases so far with much more use.