We’ve owned our AF 27-5L for over 2 years and have spent times in it winter camping with temps in the 20s. Haven’t owned any of the other two brands you mentioned. Ours has dual pane windows which I feel helps with along with the insulation to keep it cozy warm. The best part is we don’t look through condensation on the windows and have that damp feeling.
For extreme low temps in an AF but different model check out this link.....http://www.nroa2003.com/forum/forum/message-board/modifications/266979-random-thoughts-and-ideas-regarding-cold-weather-rving. it really tells the story to how good an Arctic Fox is