While both floorplans as you stated are very much alike, it looks like the beds in the BH are larger in the Cougar. To me, the other big diff is that the kit/LR are opposite and FWIW, I think I'd rather have the LR on curb side. ANOTHER thing I noticed is that w/ the GD, the awnings are pretty close to each other and when extended can make for a very large "connected" shaded area. Add drop down awning screens and now a nice little private place OR prop up the screens and extend area out further if possible. We can do this w/ our BC and it's nice. Just a thought.
But opinions is what you asked for so I'd opt for the GD. In saying that tho, I like the looks of the new Cougars too. Best thing is to take the whole family to each one and see how you all fit inside (boys on bunk beds), move around, DW w/ kitchen layout etc. GD seems to have very good reviews BUT keep in mind, they use the same vendors like everyone else and have same problems as well. But, all in all, GD gets my vote.
