Hi daystrom,
I think you’ll find
this thread sticky helpful. You’ll find complete details on how much you save at Pilot Flying J using each of the 2 ways to save on fuel:
1. Good Sam Club Swipe & Save Membership Card
2. Pilot Flying J RV Plus Charge Card
What may be causing some confusion is that the pumps at Pilot Flying J prompt you to insert your “loyalty card.” Here’s a helpful FAQ from GoodSamClub.com that addresses this:
Why am I seeing a "please see cashier" message at the pump?When using the Swipe & Save card with your personal debit/credit card, first swipe your debit/credit card at the pump. The pump will prompt you to insert your loyalty card--this is when you use your Swipe & Save Good Sam Club membership card. If you use the Swipe & Save card first, the pump will present a "Please see cashier" message.
The myrewards card you’re referring to is a Pilot Flying J preferred customer card offering deals in Pilot Flying J Travel Centers & restaurants, but not fuel savings.
Sincerely,
Good Sam Club Team