Forum Discussion

Cdurham's avatar
Cdurham
Explorer
Jul 18, 2013

Deciding is hard work - help

We have four of the following MH to choose from, please give feedback before we buy.
2010 - Fleetwood Southwind 32V - gas 10 k miles (least price tag)
2013 - Thor Palazzo - Diesel used 5K miles, also looking at a new one
2013 - Fleetwood Excursion - Diesel new
2013 - Tiffin Allegro - Diesel new

They all have something that we like about them, but none with 100% perfect floorplan. Please post you thoughts.
Thanks

20 Replies

  • quite the varied list. If you can afford a new diesel, you will not be happy with a fifteen year old gasser, just cross that one off.

    The Palazzo's are interesting to me. One of those new wave eco friendly little DP's, but still a real DP. I'd consider one if the floorplan would work.

    The others are "vanilla". If you can afford it, either will make you happy for a long long time.
  • Altern wrote:
    crasster wrote:
    For me I shop for the best deal. Price matters always. I am willing to sacrifice a few luxuries for a much better deal. I look for function always and not luxury ever.
    I disagree. IMHO: always buy quality if available - life is short enough as it is.
    Why wait to splurge on the casket..:B
    X-2. If I could afford it, and it was on the OPs list, I would have said Foretravel!!! Am extremely happy with my 1994 Foretravel. It doesn't show its age, except for peeling decals! I moved up from a 1994 Tiffin Allegro because it showed it age, and I did not like how it handled on the highway. Not saying it was bad, just that it showed it age and the 28 foot long P32 handling was crappy.
  • crasster wrote:
    For me I shop for the best deal. Price matters always. I am willing to sacrifice a few luxuries for a much better deal. I look for function always and not luxury ever.
    I disagree. IMHO: always buy quality if available - life is short enough as it is.
    Why wait to splurge on the casket..:B
  • The Tiffin is the better coach in my opinion, for what it's worth!
  • crasster wrote:
    For me I shop for the best deal. Price matters always. I am willing to sacrifice a few luxuries for a much better deal. I look for function always and not luxury ever. Never about "cheapness".

    For instance, I don't need a granite countertop in my coach, just a regular good quality one is fine. I don't need tiles, but standard flooring that is good is fine.

    That's the way I decide on things. I take everything into consideration, and figure the best deal.

    For others the granite may matter, so they'd take that into consideration.

    It is a very hard, big, and expensive decision. Sometimes it helps to write everything down in a T chart (or multiple T chart) with lots of columns. Cross out and put check marks (or pluses and minuses) next to everything you like, don't care about, or dislike.

    Sometimes hard decisions are easy to make if you lay it out on paper like that.


    I agree that this is probably the best approach. Find the floorplan that BEST suits your needs. Then figure out if the extra costs for the other items on the other coaches are actually worth it. As you read the various forums, you will find that it is extremely rare for anyone to wear out the drive train so gas or diesel is equal on longevity. Determine what you plan to do with the RV. If you plan to tow in excess of 5000 pounds, you will probably have to go with the diesel. Always keep in mind that the newer the coach, the new the systems, appliances, electronics, furniture, and chassis components are. Customer service is great, but doesn't help you too much when you are thousands of miles away from the factory.
  • For me I shop for the best deal. Price matters always. I am willing to sacrifice a few luxuries for a much better deal. I look for function always and not luxury ever. Never about "cheapness".

    For instance, I don't need a granite countertop in my coach, just a regular good quality one is fine. I don't need tiles, but standard flooring that is good is fine.

    That's the way I decide on things. I take everything into consideration, and figure the best deal.

    For others the granite may matter, so they'd take that into consideration.

    It is a very hard, big, and expensive decision. Sometimes it helps to write everything down in a T chart (or multiple T chart) with lots of columns. Cross out and put check marks (or pluses and minuses) next to everything you like, don't care about, or dislike.

    Sometimes hard decisions are easy to make if you lay it out on paper like that.
  • Cdurham wrote:
    We have four of the following MH to choose from, please give feedback before we buy.
    2010 - Fleetwood Southwind 32V - gas 10 k miles (least price tag)
    2013 - Thor Palazzo - Diesel used 5K miles, also looking at a new one
    2013 - Fleetwood Excursion - Diesel new
    2013 - Tiffin Allegro - Diesel new

    They all have something that we like about them, but none with 100% perfect floorplan. Please post you thoughts.
    Thanks


    If you can afford it the Tiffin would be my choice... Excellent customer service and warranty... Family owned business... This comes from ownship of a Newer 45' ZEPHYR not just throwing a unsubstanciated opinion out...

    Tim

    Tim