Forum Discussion
DrewE
Aug 08, 2018Explorer II
theoldwizard1 wrote:ron.dittmer wrote:
There are three main reasons to get a Mercedes Sprinter or Ford Transit diesel in the shorter lengths.
1) You plan to rack up many many miles, ..
2) The rig you love most is offered only in a diesel.
3) You simply like the idea of owning a diesel
Otherwise I feel you would be better off with a Ford E350 chassis, or the Chevy 3500 chassis.
Concur !
I guess the 4th would be you are planning on towing a large vehicle or heavy trailer and need the extra power.
Other than some additional power and maybe better resale, there really is no justification to buy a diesel these days with all of the emission controls that have ruined the fuel economy.
If you're getting a Sprinter-based or diesel Transit-based motorhome, there's no extra power to be had over the E series chassis, and I suspect in real-life use a little less power (though, since they tend to be smaller motorhomes as well, the overall performance evens out). If you get a super-C based on a heavier duty truck chassis, that's a different matter altogether.
What is undoubtedly true is that the Ford V10 needs to rev high, and makes a good bit of commotion in the process, to be in its power band, while a diesel will be operating at a lower RPM under load. Some people don't like the high revving; if you operate the V10 at a more sedate RPM, it will tend to be rather lackluster.
About Motorhome Group
38,707 PostsLatest Activity: Feb 20, 2025