Both are great products. We are on our second Tiffin because of the way they stand behind their product. On my last coach they continued to repair things that I believed that I should have paid for without my asking. An example being that we had a window fog after eight years. When I replaced it they did not charge anything as they felt there were some problem windows that year. They truly stand behind their product long after the warranty expires. We feel that the quality of our coach is excellent and I have not seen a paint job that is any better. We have found that most people that talk badly about Tiffin coaches have never owned one. It is usually a story about what somebody else has said. We are very pleased with ours and will definitely buy another.