Forum Discussion

Dream_Chaser_'s avatar
Nov 20, 2015

Traffic violation in a Class A

Not sure where to post this so here goes.

I was pulled over in NY state for a traffic violation -- coasted down a hill and was stopped for speeding. The officer came up to the side window and after asking for the necessary documentation asked if there was anyone else in the motor home. I said yes and pointed to my partner who was sitting in the bucket seat behind the passenger seat.

She had recently undergone major foot surgery and had turned the passenger seat around so she could rest her foot on it. She had on her factory seat belt but the officer said it was illegal. No explanation from him.

Does this mean that you cannot have passengers belted in on the 2nd passenger seat and/or sofa or dinette where seat belts are provided?

He made sure she moved up to the front seat before he allowed me to move.

The speeding violation was not out of reach but this county added a $93 surcharge on the fine. That upset me. And with the Canadian dollar at $.75 US it sure added up.
  • rgatijnet1 wrote:
    It used to be the law in New York State that only front seat adults had to be wearing a seat belt. Adults in the back seat did not have to buckle up. NY seat belts

    It says, 'every occupant regardless of age or seating position must be restrained.'
    It does not dictate where you must sit in the vehicle.
    Interesting. Hopefully someone has the answer. Or maybe the LEO was wrong?
  • This is one I want an answer to also. If said passenger was in a seat installed by the manufacturer and using the seatbelt (or other passenger restraint system) also installed by the manufacturer, it has to be legal unless New York has recently adopted new laws that make no sense what so ever. (But then, this is NY we are talking about.)

    Matt - a refugee of the east coast
  • It used to be the law in New York State that only front seat adults had to be wearing a seat belt. Adults in the back seat did not have to buckle up. NY seat belts
  • Did you ask him why it is illegal? I would contact him or his department and inquire.

    I don't know why it matters where you sit as long as you're wearing the seat belt.

    Maybe a member familiar with NY laws will respond with an answer.