RoyB wrote:
We use the Coleman Road Trip and it meets all of our cooking needs.. The Weber Q Series probably has a better seal with its tight lid etc... Some folks like that idea for better heat distribution in the cooking area...
I like the Coleman Road trip for all of the accessories including the nice stand etc that can be purchased for it and all fits in a nice roll around two wheeled tote...
The Coleman Road trip runs off of a single 1LB propane canister and has two burners... Also has a water reservoir around the burners in a tray that makes for very easy cleanup...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e1189/e1189c76a1457d72cf16cf04ae1c0dfc8bf9ce0b" alt=""
We have been using our setup since 2008
Roy Ken
I tried to like the roadtrip.I had the bag and all the accesories.
Everything was great except the darn thing did not heat that well.
I camp in some pretty cold conditions some times and the Roadtrip would struggle to get hot.
The Weber Q does not have the built in stand or quite as many accessories. It is not quite as convenient to use as the Roadtrip. However it does get hot under all conditions which trumps all other factors. A grill that does not get hot is of no use to me.
I eventually sold all of my Roadtrip stuff on Craigslist and have become a Weber Q convert.:C