I know there are many topics on this, but after reading through them, I still don’t know what’s my best route. I’m looking at purchasing a Winegard Carryout G3 and getting a receiver for my RV. My question is, what receiver do I need to buy that will work with my G3 and do I just contact Direct TV and get another card for the new receiver? My extra TVs at home cost me an additional $7 month so I’m assuming it will cost me $7 more to have this in my RV. Am I on the right track, or am I missing something? Thanks for any input.PS my extra TVs at home are Genie Mini connected through a bridge to my base unit a Genie Gen 2 Hr44-200.

I can't speak as intelligently as some on this subject but I can tell you that since you are speaking of Direct TV....be very careful what you purchase for a Carryout System. As you probably already know, Direct TV has some changes coming down the pike. Thus, only certain receivers, at some point will be necessary in order to get signals from the 101 Satellite. Its going to be very confusing so rather than going into it, I will say this, I've had Direct TV for 20 years and have used Direct TV in the RV via a Roof Dome, a roof mounted non dome and a portable Dish. When this change occurs, only certain receivers would allow me to continue using the three dishes mentioned BUT these receivers are not so easily obtainable. Long story short, I'm giving up on Direct at least in the RV for now. I will switch over to Dish Network (home and RV) sometime in the near future. I'm sure someone will come along and explain this much better than I!!!

Thanks for the reply. After surfing around the net and doing some more reading, I’m hearing a lot of the same. Since I’m out of contract with Direct TV, maybe it’s time to make a switch. Again, thanks for the reply, hopefully others will chime in as well. My daughter recently switched to Hulu TV at home and seems happy with it and at a considerable savings. Maybe I need to look at that for home and Dish for the RV. Decisions, decisions.

I know exactly how you feel...decisions-decisions!!!! Honestly, I'm thinking "Streaming" may be a viable option but many places I RV don't have such great coverage for Data. Oh well...Good Luck!

The question about receivers is not really in question at all. You just have to have an HD receiver to receive DTV programming in the near future (some are now reporting 2021). I suggest the H24 model or HR24 if you want a DVR. This will work today receiving only SD programming (true with any dome model antenna) and will work when the change happens someday. If/when this change happens your dome will start receiving programming in HD which will be a great improvement. What remains in question is which channels will be available since only the programming being broadcast from the 101 satellite can be picked up by a dome.You can actually take your Genie in the RV when you travel if you like and have all your recorded programming on the road as well. You can't just bring a client as they are not receivers. You would have to add the SWM 8 hardware between the dome and the receiver but that's pretty easy and cheap.If you plan to dump DTV and have DISH installed at home just be aware that DISH uses 2 different sets of 3 satellites to cover the US so which set you are assigned to at home can affect which dome you should buy. You will also need a wide open sky to catch all 3 satellites as they are spread across 20 degrees of sky.

Bill is correct for the most part, but the reference to Dish needing "wide open sky" is an exaggeration. That 20 deg spread is at ~22,500 miles away from the single aiming point at your dish, so the gap needed through tree cover is really quite small. In 10 years of setting up our portable dish at a couple of hundred campsites, most with some sort of tree cover, we've always been able to get the Dish sat signals from one arc set or the other. And we never choose sites for the "satellite view", just the "scenic view".

Portable Satellite Antenna | Good Sam Community

mxdad777
Explorer
Dec 16, 2019
Thanks for the reply. After surfing around the net and doing some more reading, I’m hearing a lot of the same. Since I’m out of contract with Direct TV, maybe it’s time to make a switch. Again, thanks for the reply, hopefully others will chime in as well.
My daughter recently switched to Hulu TV at home and seems happy with it and at a considerable savings. Maybe I need to look at that for home and Dish for the RV. Decisions, decisions.
Acampingwewillg
Explorer II
Dec 16, 2019
I can't speak as intelligently as some on this subject but I can tell you that since you are speaking of Direct TV....be very careful what you purchase for a Carryout System. As you probably already know, Direct TV has some changes coming down the pike. Thus, only certain receivers, at some point will be necessary in order to get signals from the 101 Satellite.

Its going to be very confusing so rather than going into it, I will say this, I've had Direct TV for 20 years and have used Direct TV in the RV via a Roof Dome, a roof mounted non dome and a portable Dish. When this change occurs, only certain receivers would allow me to continue using the three dishes mentioned BUT these receivers are not so easily obtainable. Long story short, I'm giving up on Direct at least in the RV for now. I will switch over to Dish Network (home and RV) sometime in the near future.

I'm sure someone will come along and explain this much better than I!!!

Forum Discussion

Portable Satellite Antenna

About RV Must Haves

Related Content

Portable Satellite

Truck SiriusXM satellite radio antenna.

Purchasing a portable satellite antenna, which one????

Installing Satellite radio antenna

satellite radio and gps antenna