Forum Discussion

caseyod81's avatar
caseyod81
Explorer
Jul 07, 2016

Travel trailer or a motorized rv w/ toad??

Hey everyone. I am brand new to RVing and do not have one yet. I'm 23 years old, so on a small budget.. but would like to dive into to full time RVing around the U.S. I have 2 pets, 1 dog 1 cat, that are a big concern of mine (especially for giving my cat space). My boyfriend is going with me but neither of us are mechanically savvy. We keep flip flopping between buying a large SUV and a travel trailer, or buying a class A or C to tow my current car with. My car weighs about 3000 lbs. Here are my main concerns:
1) Money. I don't mind financing but would rather keep it to a small amount. Ideally I would like to spend 6,000 up front and keep financing to a minimum. Gas is also an issue. We will be mainly going campsite to campsite with the RV but will take the vehicle out for site seeing and grocery shopping.
2) Reliability and safety. I know with my budget this is the hardest part. The reason why I am insisting on a vehicle and an RV is so if something goes wrong with one, at least I'll still have either a vehicle or a home. I of course, would prefer if nothing goes wrong.. but things happen.
3) Ease of driving. I'm a pretty good driver.. but I've never driven something so big so it makes me a bit nervous. I already plan on getting back up cameras.

With that said, I would really appreciate some advice. Here is what I'm looking at so far:
a) A Nissan Armada or Toyota Sequoia ($8,000-$10,000 with less than 175,000 miles) and some cheap old 80's-90's travel trailers ($3,000-$5,000). I do want an SUV so the cat can be in a crate in the trunk while driving and the dog can have the back seat.
b) A class A or C that can tow my 3,000 lb mazda (would tow on a dolly). The RVs in my price range (up to $12,000) seem to be mainly 80's models with a range of mileage (from 20,000 to 100,000).

I was leaning more towards a motorized RV and then towing my car.. until and RV sales person said that anything in my price range for a motorized RV would be a money pit and would be hard to find mechanics for while on the road. But my thought process is if worse comes to worse if it breaks down and is too costly to repair, just sell it for what I can and drive on back home in my car. I may be a bit biased since my car is my baby and I don't want to sell it! In all fairness its 2008 with 90,000 miles and hasn't had a single issue ever!

Sorry this is lengthy. I'm just a complete loss of what to do and would love some feedback from more experienced people!
  • I started RVing with a TT and pickup truck. I decided that I would rather have a MH and tow my car, a Subaru. The MH was new at the time. My MH is now 11 years old and still going strong.

    Some things to consider are; however I am probably biased.
    The MH gets 9 mpg, the toad gets close to 30 mpg. Good for exploring local attractions.
    Towing a car gives you 2 engines in case one breaks down.
    Towing a trailer is probably less costly.
  • Yeah, I vote for the SUV and trailer. An old MH is not for the faint of heart, especially since you are planning to travel a lot. If you get a trailer, spend some money getting the springs, brakes, tires, & bearings replaced by someone who seems to know what they are doing. Suspension is the weak part of travel trailers. Like 1940's technology meets Chinese quality control.

    My other advice would be not to buy something which takes the SUV's tow rating to the limit. Leave yourself a lot of room. Towing a moderate load is not too bad. Towing a full load is miserable.
  • You've given pretty good arguments for both sides, a towable trailer or a drivable MH. Either way, buying used, you truly never know what you're REALLY getting until you get it and start using it. So, its probably a 50-50 toss up.

    It boils down to what kind of camping you want to do. But, here's something you need to consider also.... insurance.

    For the towable trailer, your insurance is covered when hitched up. (theoretically, you don't need to carry insurance on your trailer as it's covered when in tow). You can carry a separate policy. Then the separate policy, or rider, will cover damage when NOT attached to the tow vehicle, which costs much less than insurance on a vehicle with an engine.

    On the other hand, with 2 vehicles with engines, you have to pay insurance for both. If this is the straw that breaks the camel's back, then you want to go with a trailer as your insurance will be less for both TT and tow vehicle, opposed to a Motor Home and the Nissan.

    Another fine point to consider. When towing a trailer, you can usually back up with no issues. When towing a vehicle, especially on a dolly, you have to unhitch the pulled vehicle so you can back up. If you find yourself in a position where you have to back up, this might be anther straw to break that camel's back.

    yes... lots to consider.

    Others can chime in, pros and cons. In your situation, I still see a 50-50 coin flip. Good luck in your choice.
  • Welcome to the forum.
    I have a 96 Southwind Class A.
    That said, I think you are better off with a travel trailer and tow vehicle.
    There are good deals on older travel trailers available. Just do some research.

    You need to learn what to look for in a used TT. One big thing, RV tires usually age out before they wear out. So, check the age of the tires on any RV you are considering. Most RVers replace tires at 6-9 years. Some sooner.

    You apparently like the Armada. They're pretty nice. But, don't overlook the Chevy Suburban or Ford Expedition. Or the beast, a Ford Excursion.
    Or even, a crew cab truck.

    Start doing research and ask questions. There is a lot of experience and information on the forum.
  • Go with the SUV and trailer. You RV sales dude was spot on about the old motor home being a money pit. Just make sure the trailer has good bearings, brakes and tires. That is really the only thing that will give you a break down on the side of the road. If the fridge goes out, take it out and throw it away. Buy a small 110v fridge at Walmart <$200. If your heat goes out, get an electric space heater. If your stove quits, use an electric skillet or small outside grill to cook. If the SUV breaks down that is a different story, it could become a money pit as well, but at least you will still have a place to stay. Worst case scenario, sell them both for what you can get and buy a bus ticket home. Go see the USA and have fun while you can. Wish I would have done that when I was young, but I probably would never have went back home.