Forum Discussion

miklman's avatar
miklman
Explorer
Aug 28, 2013

3500 dodge laramie vs 2001 ford f250

which of these performs better when towing a 2005 3400 rl montana 5er?

8 Replies

  • Depends on your definition of performance. Yours is probably not the same as mine by a long shot.
  • Skid.. my dually was $5500.00 total.. LOL. I missed the upgrade bus.. bahahahaha
  • brirene wrote:
    Crowe wrote:
    Brand irrelevant, a larger, more powerful truck in most cases is going to perform "better" just by sheer physics alone. Erring on the side of caution is rarely a bad thing.


    Agree. One ton will handle that unit much better.
    AGREEEEED!!!!

    Never, ever buy a dinky 3/4 ton, (that is totally sufficient.....) if you can get buying the 1 ton for only $15,000 more, past your wife.










    :B
  • Depends, are we talking 360 vs 5.4 V8, 8.0 vs 6.8 V10's, or PowerStroke vs Cummins?

    I give the edge to the Ford Gassers and the edge to the Cummins in the diesel. The V10's will handle it, they will be thirsty though. I do agree, the one ton dually would be a better fit...although if you watch the numbers you may be able to get away with a SRW.

    Also, the payload on those early F250's was VERY light weight... as in my FIL has a Lariat F250 4x4 PSD and he was within 300-500 lbs of payload on my old 97 F150.

    thanks!

    Jeremiah
  • Crowe wrote:
    Brand irrelevant, a larger, more powerful truck in most cases is going to perform "better" just by sheer physics alone. Erring on the side of caution is rarely a bad thing.


    Agree. One ton will handle that unit much better.
  • Brand irrelevant, a larger, more powerful truck in most cases is going to perform "better" just by sheer physics alone. Erring on the side of caution is rarely a bad thing.
  • I fulltimed in the 3400 for several years and I don't think I would use the 250.