wtmtnhiker wrote:
We have had Passport America since 2010. It has saved us allot of money. There are some restrictions that vary from one campground to another but overall it's a great value. We typically get the membership fee paid for in two nights stay.
we had Passport America for a year but did not renew it. the problems? simply put PA campgrounds were not located where we were at the end of the driving day. and on the rare occasion when a PA park was nearby at the end of our day the restrictions were numerous...wrong day of week, wrong month of the year, etc. we prefer to travel the way we want to travel and not be forced to follow a route dictated by a campground discount program.
we've belonged to Good Sam for nearly 30-years now and while the discount offered is "only" 10% it has paid for itself many times over. and some parks that don't belong to GS that are in competition with a nearby park that does belong to GS will offer the 10% discount to GS members.
but the OP would be wise to determine what type of RV travel they are planning to do. if the OP is planning on a lot of 1, 2 or 3-night stays at campgrounds then he will do well with the GS program, the AAA program, AARP program...or even the PA program (assuming they have parks where he will be going). but if they are planning to stay a week or more at any given location then they will be dollars ahead by taking advantage of the park's own weekly or monthly rates. these days we normally spend 1-2 weeks at a camp and take advantage of the camp's discount and then use GS for those 1-night stays while on the road.
for example. when in the Tucson, AZ area we usually stay at the Benson I-10 park in Benson, AZ. their nightly rate (+ tax) is $37, $33 with GS, AAA, AARP, etc., $20 with PA. but if you plan to stay a week their weekly rate (incl tax) is $125 or $17.85 per day. virtually every commercial campground will have a weekly and/or a monthly rate.
a discount program is good only if you plan to actually use it.