Forum Discussion

SpeakEasy's avatar
SpeakEasy
Explorer
Jul 27, 2016

What Was She Thinking?

Sixty-some years ago two post-war, baby-boom parents began teaching their son about looking both ways before crossing a road, and then proceeding only if it was safe. Since they did not live in a city, they didn’t worry too much about teaching him about crosswalks. It was almost an after-thought, but when they did spend time in cities they taught him to use crosswalks when he needed to cross the street. But the rules of looking both ways and proceeding when safe were the bedrock procedure they taught.

A dozen years or so ago some (possibly) well-meaning legislator decided that pedestrians on a crosswalk should have the right-of-way over oncoming traffic, and he or she persuaded a majority of lawmakers to go along with this. At the stroke of a pen, common sense had a stroke.

Since I first heard about this new, upside-down law giving pedestrians in a crosswalk the right-of-way I have been worried about its unintended consequences. I have adjusted my driving to accommodate it, but I have not changed my street-crossing algorithm. Just because I can step out into oncoming traffic if I step into a crosswalk, that does not change my internal wiring. I still look both ways and proceed only when it’s safe. And I still use crosswalks when I have to cross a street in a city.

Yesterday I was driving home from a camping trip towing my 2-and-a-half ton travel trailer. I was traveling below the speed limit (30MPH) in the City of Canandaigua. I was on a side street. I was paying attention to my driving, but there was also a lot going on inside the car, with my wife on the phone and my 5-year-old granddaughter in the back chattering away. As I got near one of the many crosswalks in the city my eyes did pick up a pedestrian on the left, approaching the crosswalk. I was close enough to the crosswalk that I decided that it would be unsafe to try to stop. My total weight with trailer and truck was close to 10,000 pounds (5 tons.) No matter what, it takes a pretty good distance to stop 10,000 pounds moving along at nearly 30 miles per hour.

Yes; this pedestrian did look me in the eye and yes, there was a look of defiance there as she stepped out into the crosswalk.

-Speak
  • Twice I've almost hit people. One time the setting sun was right behind the fellow and I was partially blinded and almost didn't see him. The second was three Goth girls, all dressed in black jay walking across an unlit residential street right in front of me, almost daring me to hit them. I suggested to them that if they were going to play that game to be fair to their "opponent" they may want to wear white.

    Steve
  • Seems simple to me.
    Pedestrians have the right of way once they are in the cross walk.
  • It's scary to drive through places like Gatlinburg, TN that have laws like this. People will be standing on the curb with their back to the street and suddenly turn and walk out into traffic because they have the right of way.
  • The law isn't new, it's been around for many years. At least in this area.
    The law also states, no pedestrian shall walk suddenly into the path of a vehicle..
    But, we all know that happens all the time.

    About all you can do is be very careful and hope you don't encounter someone who makes a living by walking in front of vehicles while in a cross walk. :E

    People walking on the road? It's probably easier on the road than the berm.
    Or, it's just 'all about me' people.... There are a lot of them out there.
  • SpeakEasy wrote:


    A dozen years or so ago some (possibly) well-meaning legislator decided that pedestrians on a crosswalk should have the right-of-way over oncoming traffic, and he or she persuaded a majority of lawmakers to go along with this.

    As I got near one of the many crosswalks in the city my eyes did pick up a pedestrian on the left, approaching the crosswalk. I was close enough to the crosswalk that I decided that it would be unsafe to try to stop.


    You knew you were supposed to stop, you saw a pedestrian. You choose to keep on driving through the crosswalk. You were wrong.

    For the life of me, why would it have been "unsafe" to try to stop?
  • I agree completely! On similar note, why do people find it necessary to walk in the street...........4 feet from a sidewalk! I`m seeing this more and more! you have to drive around them into the oncoming lane to avoid them. the worst is parents pushing a stroller!!!!!! this is so common by me its ridiculous!
  • Tvov's avatar
    Tvov
    Explorer II
    "College towns" (or cities) are the worst. The kids just waltz across the street without a care in the world. I have two kids in college, and they confuse their friends by actually looking both ways before walking into a road.
  • That's how I was raised. Even on an Army base, you looked both ways before crossing. But downtown Minneapolis - jaywalking, crosswalk, it doesn't matter. Most people do look before crossing, but there's a small percentage of people who really do seem bent on crossing RIGHT in front of a vehicle.

    Yes, for RV'ers it seems like we have to really look around because, well, some people are just...ignorant. I never had to do a complete panic stop while towing, but I have had to slam on my brakes fairly hard to slow down to avoid wildlife.

    I would surmise if some pedestrians were forced to go through a simulation of a 10,000 lb load slowing down from 45 to 0 and having a simulated pedestrian in front of them - they might think twice about their behavior.
  • well-meaning legislator decided that pedestrians on a crosswalk should have the right-of-way over oncoming traffic, and he or she persuaded a majority of lawmakers to go along with this. At the stroke of a pen, common sense had a stroke.


    Boy do I hear you!

    Just try driving thru Lake Geneva, Wisconsin.

    It is a resort town and when they passed that law what they have there now is people purposely walking right in front of a car to make them stop. The out of town vacationer pedestrians have made it a game.

    AND....they don't have to be in a marked cross walk either.

    And the cops sit there handing out tickets to the DRIVERS who don't slam on their brakes to let these idiot pedestrians who walk across right in front of their vehicles. :R:R

About RV Tips & Tricks

Looking for advice before your next adventure? Look no further.25,114 PostsLatest Activity: Feb 22, 2025