Forum Discussion

MEXICOWANDERER's avatar
Dec 21, 2017

ABC News Quote " "

The Sierra Club — the environmental group that blew the whistle on FEMA when Hurricane Katrina victims were given toxic RV trailers to live in — has warned that some mobile homes en route to victims of the California wildfires have the same excessive formaldehyde levels that sickened some Katrina victims.

The Federal Emergency Management Agency has confirmed that 50 new mobile homes from a Hope, Ark., storage facility are already on their way to Southern California as part of the federal relief effort for thousands who lost their homes to fires in October.

"We have started the transition," said James McIntyre, a spokesman for FEMA, which has been phasing out its use of "travel trailers" in favor of mobile homes.

FEMA claims that its mobile homes are safe, but concedes it has not tested these units, which were manufactured with materials similar to those in the toxic RV trailers.

But Sierra Club says random tests of FEMA mobile homes found at least three had formaldehyde levels over the Environmental Protection Agency limit of .10 parts per million.

Previous Sierra Club testing showed that 83 percent of FEMA homes tested in Mississippi, Louisiana and Alabama had levels of formaldehyde above the recommended limit.

"We have reason to question the safety of emergency homes going to California," said Sierra spokesman Oliver Bernstein. "FEMA had a grand solution not to give out the trailers and to give out mobile homes, and they think they have done their homework."

Formaldehyde is a toxic chemical most often used for embalming, but it is also commonly used as a glue in building materials, like particle board for cabinets in mobile homes. It can "out-gas," or leak into the air, under hot, humid conditions.

35 Replies

  • Let me see if I have this straight: a group advises people that certain buildings possibly being used for disaster relief may cause harm to the people using them. And they get vilified for this? Is this known as hanging the messenger? Maybe we could also ship the disaster areas blankets that have previously been used to cover small pox victims?

    If I were in need of shelter I might be forced to use a trailer that has issues with high formaldehyde, but it would be nice to know the danger exists. You know, kind of a heads up thing.
  • I had bought a particle board bookcase years ago and set it up in my bedroom. Had ventilation and the bedroom was the size of a 2-car garage. Put it up around 11pm. The next morning I woke up at about 7 am and my eyes were glued shut from caked on gook. The formaldehyde caused my eyes to excrete the gook during the night. Had to take drops for a week to stop the gooking (even after taking the bookcase out).

    So, I do understand the problem with excess formaldehyde. Even though mine was just an inconvenience, it did take me out of work for several days - and I did not get paid for being out.

    And I do understand the need to bring these issues to the public's attention in order to get them corrected.

    However, I do wish when a large powerful group speaks out, that they would offer help in obtaining a solution.

    What does the Sierra Club think should be done? What are they willing to do to help make those changes? Or is it just a "I don't like what you're doing so do something else".
  • azrving wrote:
    Nothing? tent? cheesy rv? cheesy mobile? I'll take cheesy RV or mobile with a window open. Sierra club get lost


    X2 if my house and belongs were reduced to ashes I'd be happy to breathe some formaldehyde for a little while in order to have a roof over my head.

    Just because they're above "recommended levels" doesn't mean toxic levels.
  • Nothing? tent? cheesy rv? cheesy mobile? I'll take cheesy RV or mobile with a window open. Sierra club get lost
  • Transport them with windows open

    Besides.....CA is not Hot & Humid


    700+ homes destroyed......guess those folks just have to fend for themselves unless 'Sierra Club' plans on putting them up in their homes or paying the bill for housing ????

About Technical Issues

Having RV issues? Connect with others who have been in your shoes.24,288 PostsLatest Activity: Jan 09, 2022