Forum Discussion

93ToyTruck's avatar
93ToyTruck
Explorer
Jan 19, 2016

Cooler Unit Replacement - New or Refurbished?

My refrigerator went out. Propane and 120v produce heat but it doesn't cool. There is no sign of a leak.

I think my cooling unit went out due to heat and lack of ventilation. I keep my RV in the California desert and run the refrigerator about 8 months out of the year. My RV is level and stays in the same location so I don't think it being level was a contributing factor. The temp is often 90 to 100+ degrees and I didn't have any fans installed. When I get a new unit, I plan on installing a few 5" fans at the top of the vent in addition to one of the fan kits that mount to the refrigerator. It's still going to be hot outside but I'll keep the air flowing through.

I'm trying to decide between a new or refurbished cooling unit.

I don't think I would benefit from the new units that are thicker because leaking and operating the refrigerator off level isn't the issue I need to overcome. They don't do anything extra to address the cooling which is my problem.

My concern about a refurbished unit is that it seems like the condition of the unit they refurbish is random luck. How do they know that it doesn't have a weak spot because a leak was developing but didn't surface?

Any recommendations on vendors?
  • you guys might re think puting in new units there cheaper made than your old one. and rebuilts are of a heavier material.
  • Big Katuna wrote:
    When mine went, there was no doubt in my mind; new unit.

    If I'm going to put in all that labor, I'm putting in a new unit.


    +1
  • The RV isn't moving and the nearest service facility is about 50 miles away so a tech isn't an option. I called and talked to the guy that manufactures the new 'Amish' replacements. He was the person that said the heat probably did it in. After researching, it makes a lot of sense.

    I'm on an off-grid solar system that produces about 1300 watts peak. I created a device to turn the inverter on/off depending on the panel output. In the hot season, it runs my AC when I'm not there. When it's not hot, I run the refrigerator on auto. It gets 120v during the day then propane at night.

    Warranty on a new unit is 5 years. Warranty on refurbished units are 2-3 years and coverage varies. Some are worded "defects in manufacturing" vs. leak.
  • What is difference in cost and warranty between the 2 options.....reman or new?

    IF new is using thicker walled tubing then I would be inclined to go that direction.

    20 yr (+) old fridges are still functioning because they were built using thicker walled tubing.

    10 yr (-) old have a higher failure rate.....thinner tubing used/poorer quality welding

    RV Cooling 3/5 yr warranty
  • When mine went, there was no doubt in my mind; new unit.

    If I'm going to put in all that labor, I'm putting in a new unit.
  • When my Dometic went belly-up near Tucson, I told the RV service person to fix it like it was his own. He put in a rebuilt unit.
  • Are you plugged in most of the time? Consider a residential compressor fridge.
  • What warranty is provided with a referb as compared to the warranty on a new cooling unit. I would wonder if it may be appropriate to have a refrigeration tech diagnose the problem. Perhaps it isn't the cooling unit.
  • have your unit rebuilt ,place theres places that do this. one indiana I think .google rebuild rv frig.

About Technical Issues

Having RV issues? Connect with others who have been in your shoes.24,194 PostsLatest Activity: Jan 29, 2025