Forum Discussion

Adventurer_Buck's avatar
Jul 03, 2014

Holding Black Water or Flowing Through

When on a full service site, is it best to leave the black water tank open and free-flowing or is it better to treat and hold the black water with occasional dumps?

15 Replies

  • Ron3rd's avatar
    Ron3rd
    Explorer III
    Never leave your black valve open; you'll end up with a poop pyramid. Wait till nearly full, then dump.
  • Not only smell, but when you leave the blank tank open, the liquids drain out and the solids generally don't. And when the solids stay behind, you may have a major chore getting that "poop mountain" to go away.

    Keep the black tank closed until it's at least 3/4 full before you dump. Whether you leave the gray tank open or closed is optional, and you'll get advocates for either. On our rig, the black tank sensors tend to foul, but the gray tank sensors work fine. So when the grey tank shows full, we know the black tank is also probably ready for a dump.

    And if you use the park showers rather than your own, that wouldn't work very well for you.

    al
  • I usually treat the black water tank and occasionally dump it followed by dumping the grey water tank/s to "clean" the sewer hose a little.
    If you keep the black water tank "open" to the dump you might get the smell coming all the way up...

About Technical Issues

Having RV issues? Connect with others who have been in your shoes.24,344 PostsLatest Activity: Dec 31, 2025