Forum Discussion

daily_double's avatar
daily_double
Explorer
Jul 05, 2016

Another propane question

I went to fill my 20# bottle just now and the guy set the scale at 39 lbs. I told him I didn't think that would fill it but he said it would. I needed propane but I think he was wrong. Opinions?
  • The OP was about setting a scale, which involves the safety of propane. Essentially, then, it is a procedure to make sure that a given cylinder is not overfilled (a dangerous condition). It is simple mathematics: the weight of the propane plus anything else that presses down on the scale (the cylinder itself, the hoses and valves -- 6 pounds in our set-up).

    Charging for propane is completely separate and certainly does not involve considerations of safety. I suppose there are places that charge by the pound, though i haven't run across any personally. Most places will charge by the gallon (as i do) or will simply have a flat charge (which can be a bit of a rip off, imho).

    Note, then, that if we were effectively to underfill a cylinder, then it would also merely involve fewer gallons of propane and, as a result, less money on the sale.

    Lynn
  • Counting the weight of the hose it may or may not have filled it. Odds are I'm betting you filled at a place that charges by the tank which gives them incentive to short change each tank a pound or two. To make sure you are getting your money worth, always fill tanks that charge per gallon and make sure they reset the meter to zero.
  • The filler sets the scale to include the tare weight of your cylinder (varies a little; it's marked on your cylinder as TW), the weight of the propane when full (your WC X .42), and the weight of the filler's hoses.

    For a TW=18 cylinder on our system, the scale would be set to 44 pounds. It'll vary some, depending on your filler's system.

    Lynn
  • All propane tanks have a "tare weight" or "T.W." stamped on the collar of the tank. For a grill sized tank you simply calculate the tare weight + 20 lbs, and that's how much the tank should weigh when it's full. Most 20 lb tanks have a tare weight of +/- 17 pounds when completely empty.