GMH wrote:
I currently tow with an '06 2500HD with the 6.0 and 4:10 gears. It has a 4l80 4 speed auto I believe. I tow in 3rd most of the time and it will kick down to 2nd on fairly steep hills. That is why I am wondering if the 3:73 gears are too tall? They would certainly help mileage on the flatland, and I don't plan on doing a lot of traveling in the mountains...but plans change when you have beautiful vistas in front of you.
Like other posts have aptly stated, there is more at play than just the rear axle ratio, especially when comparing a 10 year old truck to today's offerings. A new HD gas truck of any flavor with 3.73 gears will outperform your 2005 with 4.10s. Having said that, if I were in the market for a gas truck for pulling a trailer of any size and weight I'd get the lowest rear axle ratio available.