We have used the Wineguard carryout for years and have had great success with it.
We have used both Dish and Directv. On the Dish, our daughter had home satellite and we added an extra box for $5/month. Kept it in the trailer and had to make a call and activate the box each trip.
On Directv, we bought a box on the internet.
We also bought an in-line satellite finder. Best investment we have ever made.
The large tripod dishes are probably nice, but the carryout is about 12" diameter and about 8" high, with a handle for carrying.
Very convenient and takes up very little space.