Forum Discussion

tcomet's avatar
tcomet
Explorer
Jun 17, 2014

F150 Question - Deciding Between Two

Hey Guys!

I am looking to pick up a new (to me) F150. We recently sold our TT and will be looking to purchase another but need the horse before the cart.

The first one is a 2005 S-Crew FX4, 3v 5.4, 3.55 rear end. Very Nice Truck, Not a scratch or ding on it with only 45K miles. This is at a dealer and prior to me picking it up they have agreed to change out the spark plugs and will also be giving, through Ford, a 3 year 36K mile power train warranty.

The Second is a 2010 F150, XTR, 5.4 w/ 3.55 rear end, S-Crew, with 75K miles, Super clean with a few more bells and whistles than the 05, This is from a private party.

Both are one owner super clean trucks. The 2010 is about $3500 more than the 2005.

Is the extra 5 years worth the $3500 and 30K miles - and the warranty? Never owning a Ford is there a huge difference between these model years?

Thanks!

21 Replies

  • Check door jamb for carrying capacity, it can vary quite a bit by year and how equipped the truck is, and could make a big difference in what you can tow.