Need to upgrade our 2004 Duramax to better tow our new, heavier fifth wheel. Want a one ton, dually, diesel, long bed, 4x4, crew cab with most available options. It would be a 2014 Dodge or Ford or a 2015 GM.Have any of you gone through this comparison recently and objectively?Prices (via Costco auto buying program) are all almost identical...dealer cost in all cases, which amounts to about $5,000 off MSRP.What were the deciding factors in your choice?

Let me make some popcorn for this thread. It will be fun to watch. Go with the Cummins... See what my Cummins tows....

Dodge with Aisin Transmission option. Fifth wheel/goose neck bed prep. The other two have the not so good Bosch CP4.2 injection pump.You pick the trim level!Chris

I would look at the ride of the truck, the payload capacity, and I would join the forums like http://www.duramaxforum.com/ and ask what the MPG's people get when towing. I really like the new Sierra's. If I were to get one tomorrow that is what I would get.

At the moment, RAM is at the towing heap top. But, very close. ALL will do fine. I love the Cummins, heaviest duty motor out there, and if you back it up with the Aisin, you will have the heaviest duty tranny too. RAM really upped their game. But, all of them will do fine too.

GM, Ford or Dodge? | Good Sam Community

deltabravo
Nomad
Feb 01, 2014
GM - A little bit nicer ride than a solid front axle equipped truck.
Hotel_Californi
Explorer
Feb 01, 2014
I am talking with Dave Smith. Thanks.
RamTC
Explorer
Feb 01, 2014
Hotel wrote:
... Want a one ton, dually, diesel, long bed, 4x4, crew cab with most available options. It would be a 2014 Dodge or Ford or a 2015 GM...

For the last 35 yrs I always bought only GM sedans/SUVs, but I prefer Dodge/Ram for HD pickups. I also got tired of waiting on GM to update the HDs and they always seem to lag a bit on the competition and could have done more for the 2015 HD release.
Goldstalker
Explorer
Feb 01, 2014
I agree $5K off is crazy check with Dave Smith Motors will be more like $15K off.

http://www.davesmith.com/specials/index.htm?category=Chrysler+Specials
larry_barnhart
Explorer
Feb 01, 2014
the 2015 ford might have more HP than their 2014. Any of the 3 is faster than our 05 that is fastest enough for me.

chevman
kaydeejay
Explorer
Feb 01, 2014
FishOnOne wrote:
What happened here! :h

I'll be waiting for the excuses! :B
Yeah well, the Ford had a 4.3 axle ratio, the Ram had 4.1 and the Chevy had a 3.73.
Not exactly a level playing field!
FishOnOne
Nomad
Feb 01, 2014
OP,
When it came time to buy my next diesel truck in '12 I test drove the RAM, Ford and kicked the tire on the Chevy, but after giving the Chevy interior one last shot I didn't either bother test driving.

After doing more due diligence I decided on another Super Duty with the 6.7 psd. Currently has ~38k miles and this truck continue to amaze me with the great fuel economy and awesome pulling power. While wrapped in a great truck package.:B

Good luck with your search.
FishOnOne
Nomad
Feb 01, 2014
rhagfo wrote:
DannyA wrote:
Just look around a campground and I think you will see Ford more than 2 to 1. There must be a reason!
I was looking for a truck and decided to see what others had bought. I quickly found that it was Ford.
Just my thoughts.

Well just because they are popular, doesn't mean they are the best!

Last King of the Hill Ford needed to use the F450 to match the Ram 3500, and it still lost!

Ram/Dodge never re-branded the Cummins, very proud the the engine choice they made and worked out in the 80's.
I went from Ford to Dodge/Ram after 45 years, next truck will be another RAM, just need to wear this one first! Currently only at 268,000 may be several more years!!

What happened here! :h

I'll be waiting for the excuses! :B
FishOnOne
Nomad
Feb 01, 2014
Me Again wrote:
Hotel California wrote:
Original poster here again. Thanks for all of the replies. Appreciate all of the opinions and facts. I think I have crossed the Ford off of the list. It may be a good truck, but there is just something about the way they look that I can't get past.

Leaning toward the RAM, but without the Aisin transmission. Will probably wait until I can actually see a new (2015) GMC Sierra Denali before we decide. Interestingly, you can no longer order a 2014 GMC, yet they cannot tell you when the 2015's will be available or what they will cost. Screwy way to run the business...

Thanks again to all.

If you buy a RAM spend the 2900 for the Aisin tranny! It is worth every extra penny.

Chris

I agree... No one in there right mind would want a Dodge 68RFE tranny.

Oh... But the Aisin is a Japanese brand tranny! I'm sure it will cost a more than a few penny's if a repair is needed. :E
FishOnOne
Nomad
Feb 01, 2014
ricatic wrote:
DannyA wrote:
Just look around a campground and I think you will see Ford more than 2 to 1. There must be a reason!
I was looking for a truck and decided to see what others had bought. I quickly found that it was Ford.
Just my thoughts.

...so does that mean that McDonalds sells the best hamburgers:B

On another note, my brother delivers trailers as a supplement to his income. He has been a Ford devotee all his life...he is as bad a Blue KoolAid drinker as I used to be...just last week we were at my mom's for a birthday. The talk inevitably turned to trucks. I was shocked when he said that he had to admit that after two years of running trailers and talking with Ram owner operators, he admitted that he understood why the Ram Cummins trucks were far and away the most popular trucks among the guy's that really work them...and his dispatch depot parking lot was most prominently populated with Ram/Cummins trucks...

After owning a POS 6.7 Ford, I would only advise that one goes Ram or GM...My stepson is driving a 2015 GM 3500 Dually DuraMax Extended Cab 4x4 at work right now...and he is quite happy with the truck...

Regards

And Burger King and Wendy's is better? :W