Kayak

I agree with the posters who recommend that you consider a canoe. We've had the same Grumman standard 17' canoe since 1970 and it still looks new. Apart form its durability we appreciate is versatility. We're not into fishing, but we love exploring rivers, streams, and ponds in the Adirondacks with our dog. We can take practically unlimited duffel in the canoe so sometimes we pack tent, ice chest, et. al. and stay out a couple of days. I have tried kayaking several times, but paddling them seems to bother my back. Something that does not happen with the canoe. Also canoes are easier to get in and out of. Regardless of what you think you want, you should go to a dealer that can let you "test drive" several kinds of kayaks and canoes so you can sort out what really works best for you.