New Truck or New Engine
So, anybody rebuilding or replacing engines in their TC hauling trucks as opposed to buying a new or low mileage used truck?
Forum Discussion
IMO, it boils down to first, your finances. You mentioned the option of new or low mile used, so presumably you can afford to upgrade. Then it becomes a matter of the “want” for a new or much newer truck and the power and conveniences afforded by something 10-15 years newer. And the peace of mind that (while anything “can” breakdown) repairs and breakdowns will be of much less of a concern.
Next is the use. Are you looking for something to get you through the short term or will you realistically be doing the same thing for another 300k miles?
3rd gen Dodges are pretty solid trucks IMO. Had an 07 since 2008, until just recently and I didn’t “want” for anything. However the 2016 that replaced it has definite advantages.
If talking just gasser pickups, I don’t see any downsides to a newer truck from any of the big 3.
Cost for the 05?
Mopar crate long block $3500-4000
Install $1500 ish
How old is the trans? Nother $1000-1500
Front end/steering?
320k rear axle? Questionable
Engine components
Other stuff (fan radiator window switches shocks brakes etc)
Make an educated decision on how much other stuff is likely to need repair in say the next 100k. With your miles should have a good idea of the lifespan of the trucks components and what has been replaced when and how long it lasted the first or second time.
Add all that up plus the residual value of your 05 which will be better than most in your area due to no rust.
Then decide how much more a new truck costs vs what you could expect to sink into yours.
Next is the use. Are you looking for something to get you through the short term or will you realistically be doing the same thing for another 300k miles?
3rd gen Dodges are pretty solid trucks IMO. Had an 07 since 2008, until just recently and I didn’t “want” for anything. However the 2016 that replaced it has definite advantages.
If talking just gasser pickups, I don’t see any downsides to a newer truck from any of the big 3.
Cost for the 05?
Mopar crate long block $3500-4000
Install $1500 ish
How old is the trans? Nother $1000-1500
Front end/steering?
320k rear axle? Questionable
Engine components
Other stuff (fan radiator window switches shocks brakes etc)
Make an educated decision on how much other stuff is likely to need repair in say the next 100k. With your miles should have a good idea of the lifespan of the trucks components and what has been replaced when and how long it lasted the first or second time.
Add all that up plus the residual value of your 05 which will be better than most in your area due to no rust.
Then decide how much more a new truck costs vs what you could expect to sink into yours.
