The one thing I really disliked about my pop-up camper I owned was the inability to ever stealth camper or do anything without drawing attention. In a normal truck camper you can pull into any Walmart, Casino parking lot, rest stop.... wherever.... and get out, and use the bathroom, take a nap, have a shower... no problem. But you can't do that with a pop-up. So to me, it depends on your lifestyle. If you plan to use it for weekends into the bushes then a pop up wins but if you plan to do long road trips then a pop up camper just doesn't work IMO.
