I couldn't disagree with the original post more. I have no interest in any forum where someone posts their thoughts and then all the following posts simply say they agree. Even in the RVing forums, there are many issues and positions that people can reasonably disagree with. Boondockers and Resort RVers are diametrically opposed in how they RV. Impassioned arguments on both sides of an issue are helpful. I was engaged on a thread recently where the issue was renting out your sticks and bricks house while full-timing. Fact of the matter is there are very strong arguments pro and con. If it wasn't for an enthusiastic conversation between supporters of both sides, the poster might not get complete information.
When people get testy, I feel it conveys the fact that they have deeply set beliefs, and that is important to know. Even when one party starts to get personal in their attacks, you learn something, because we all know that some people feel that if they can't attack the message, they must resort to attacking the messenger.