cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

CAT 450HP engine fuel mileage

tiffinboy
Explorer
Explorer
I have a friend that claims he gets 10.5 MPG at 75 mph in his 2001 450HP Cat 40Ft beaver PT motorhome and his average is 9.5??
I only get 7.5 in my ISL425 and I only drive 63MPH ?
Is this believable or?
Hes pretty smart guy about facts and figures?
18 REPLIES 18

RayChez
Explorer
Explorer
The Caterpillar engine you mentioned is huge in comparison to your ISL. It will get ten miles per gallon because it has so much power and torque that it is just cruising with the weight of the 40 foot Beaver. I have seen it on big freight trucks going 75 mph, not sure about a Beaver or any other coach going that fast.
2002 Gulf Stream Scenic Cruiser
330 HP Caterpillar 3126-E
3000 Allison Transmission
Neway Freightliner chassis
2017 Buick Envision

DSDP_Don
Explorer
Explorer
Yes he can get that mileage just before he wakes up from the dream that he's having! Even a coach that does get an occasional 10 mpg won't do it at 75 mph.

Here's what typically happens.....you have guys that never really tract their mileage, but will on occasion see that they didn't take on as much fuel as they thought they would at a particular fuel stop. They check their mileage and see they got about 9.8 and round it off to 10 mpg. What really happened was they were on an angle at the last fuel up and added an additional 5 gallons of fuel. Then they fill up angled the other way and take 5-7 gallons less than they normally would. So between the two fill ups they were off by over 10 gallons. If you drive 400 miles and take on 40 gallons you get 10 mpg. Now add in that 10 gallons of over and under fueling and you're now at 8 mpg.

The above happens often with the DP's since the tanks are almost 8' across and leaning in one direction or the other can really change how much they take. The Monaco tanks have metal pipe fillers welded on the top edge of both sides of the tank and are really susceptible to this.

We just returned from a 6300 mile trip. We started the trip and ended the trip by fueling up at the same station and in the same position. We then calculated the fuel mileage for the entire trip. We saw some 7 mpg's and some 11 mpg's, all caused by how the coach was leaning when we fueled up. We have a short and fairly light DP with a very economical ISL 400. We averaged 9.24 mpg over 6000 miles towing our truck at 58-59 mph (we only passed two other RV's). I can definitely say your friend driving 75 mph did not get 10 mpg.
Don & Mary
2019 Newmar Dutch Star 4018 - All Electric
2019 Ford Raptor Crew Cab

tiffinboy
Explorer
Explorer
Ivylog wrote:
The Cat 3406 is a great engine. 10 yes, but not at 75. 14.6L geared to run 65 at 1300 rpms in a coach that weighs 34K maybe with a tail wind.


ok never knew his ratio was so much higher than mine.Iam 1650@62
also did not know it was 14.6L engine? that's huge compared to my 8.9

Thanks for the reply

Ivylog
Explorer III
Explorer III
The Cat 3406 is a great engine. 10 yes, but not at 75. 14.6L geared to run 65 at 1300 rpms in a coach that weighs 34K maybe with a tail wind.
This post is my opinion (free advice). It is not intended to influence anyone's judgment nor do I advocate anyone do what I propose.
Sold 04 Dynasty to our son after 14 great years.
Upgraded with a 08 HR Navigator 45’...