I can't say from personal usage that Pelicans or Yetis hold up better than the Coleman Extremes BUT I can say that the Coleman Extreme 5 or 6 line beats out Igloo Maxi and Rubbermaid line IMO. Also that the Coleman Extreme Line gives a great bang for the buck.
All Colemans are not created the same as the man learned this year. He bought a 28 qt/36 can Coleman w/ wheels and telescoping handle on sale at WM this year 'cause he convinced himself that he needed a special cooler just for beers during our 3 week camping trip. Yes well whatever. Suffice to say it's a hunk a junk close to being on par w/ a Styrofoam cooler. No drain and needed ice every day. I sigh.
Right now my thinking is that our RV fridge will be a Coleman Extreme cooler stored under the dinette space so the manufacturer can install an all freezer unit in the standard space dedicated to a refrigerator.
We buy produce daily and use more freezer cubic feet at home too so this would be our norm.