Residential toilets dont belong in RVs

[tsetsaf]

Or at least the cheap ones do not. This new rig we own came with a standard tanked residential toilet. We were not fond of the idea but went with it for the last 6 weeks. Today or should I say this am was the last straw... the flap stuck just enough to trickle trickle trickle water. You know where this is heading, yes lake commode in the bathroom! This was the second and last time.

New Dometic 310 is installed. Foot flush all the way baby. Now back to drying out the storage bays.

[ol_Bombero-JC]

beemerphile1 wrote:
I would think the only RV with a residential toilet would be a park model. I can't imagine anyone dealing with a toilet tank in a towable.

Hmmmmm - - Did you read the previous posts?..:h

~

[Mike_and_Pat]

Fema trailers have residential toilets, stoves and refrigerators.

[beemerphile1]

I would think the only RV with a residential toilet would be a park model. I can't imagine anyone dealing with a toilet tank in a towable.

[Dakzuki]

BobsYourUncle wrote:

down home wrote:

BobsYourUncle wrote:
Maybe I'm missing something but I have never understood putting the big heavy porcelain thing in something that bounces down the road and sways to and fro in corners.....

I'm fine with the plastic deal and foot pedal. Actually easier than reaching for the cheap handle to flush.

And the seat feels the same.

Plastic is lighter. We have to remember, we are not towing our stick and bricks down the road..

Speaking for myself, I would pass by a unit with a residential john in favor of the standard plastic deal.

We have a porcelain RV toilet with foot pedal and spray. It doesn't move.

I guess I was thinking the same device I have in my stick & bricks, with the separate tank on top held on with 2 bolts and a rubber donut.

I've never seen an RV porcelain unit. Don't even know what they look like or how they work!
Guess I need to do some homework - haha!

They work exactly the same but are easier to keep clean.

[crabbin_cabin]

For those who have "never heard..." search for residential toilets in the Class A forum!!

[2gypsies1]

tsetsaf wrote:
This new rig we own came with a standard tanked residential toilet.
New Dometic 310 is installed. Foot flush all the way baby. Now back to drying out the storage bays.

I understood the OP to have a S&B house toilet without a foot pedal.

He then installed an RV toilet with a foot pedal.

Our RV toilet with a foot pedal is procelein but I wouldn't call it a standard tanked residential toilet. It operates just like any RV all-plastic toilet.

OP - Could you clarify what you had originally?

[Old-Biscuit]

BobsYourUncle wrote:

down home wrote:

BobsYourUncle wrote:
Maybe I'm missing something but I have never understood putting the big heavy porcelain thing in something that bounces down the road and sways to and fro in corners.....

I'm fine with the plastic deal and foot pedal. Actually easier than reaching for the cheap handle to flush.

And the seat feels the same.

Plastic is lighter. We have to remember, we are not towing our stick and bricks down the road..

Speaking for myself, I would pass by a unit with a residential john in favor of the standard plastic deal.

We have a porcelain RV toilet with foot pedal and spray. It doesn't move.

I guess I was thinking the same device I have in my stick & bricks, with the separate tank on top held on with 2 bolts and a rubber donut. That is what OP 'had' in is new 5th wheel.

I've never seen an RV porcelain unit. Don't even know what they look like or how they work! They look and operated just like an RV toilet.
The only difference is the toilet bowl is porcelain.
Have a foot pedal (or hand lever) blade valve, toilet bowl seal and a plastic pedestal.
Guess I need to do some homework - haha!

[BobsYourUncle]

down home wrote:

BobsYourUncle wrote:
Maybe I'm missing something but I have never understood putting the big heavy porcelain thing in something that bounces down the road and sways to and fro in corners.....

I'm fine with the plastic deal and foot pedal. Actually easier than reaching for the cheap handle to flush.

And the seat feels the same.

Plastic is lighter. We have to remember, we are not towing our stick and bricks down the road..

Speaking for myself, I would pass by a unit with a residential john in favor of the standard plastic deal.

We have a porcelain RV toilet with foot pedal and spray. It doesn't move.

I guess I was thinking the same device I have in my stick & bricks, with the separate tank on top held on with 2 bolts and a rubber donut.

I've never seen an RV porcelain unit. Don't even know what they look like or how they work!
Guess I need to do some homework - haha!

[down_home]

BobsYourUncle wrote:
Maybe I'm missing something but I have never understood putting the big heavy porcelain thing in something that bounces down the road and sways to and fro in corners.....

I'm fine with the plastic deal and foot pedal. Actually easier than reaching for the cheap handle to flush.

And the seat feels the same.

Plastic is lighter. We have to remember, we are not towing our stick and bricks down the road..

Speaking for myself, I would pass by a unit with a residential john in favor of the standard plastic deal.

We have a porcelain RV toilet with foot pedal and spray. It doesn't move.

[GaryWT]

Unless you are on a seasonal type site and bypassed the black tank...

[BurbMan]

Our Terry came with a porcelain RV bowl with foot flush. Best of both worlds, you get the durability and easy-to-clean of porcelain without the hassle of a tank. Can't imagine anyone installing a residential tank-type toilet in an RV. Even qt 1.5 gal/flush you wouldn't last long boondocking.

[Duck]

I have a water alarm in the bathroom, kitchen sink area, and outside in the UDC. Add one more, around the water heater.
Don

[BobsYourUncle]

Maybe I'm missing something but I have never understood putting the big heavy porcelain thing in something that bounces down the road and sways to and fro in corners.....

I'm fine with the plastic deal and foot pedal. Actually easier than reaching for the cheap handle to flush.

And the seat feels the same.

Plastic is lighter. We have to remember, we are not towing our stick and bricks down the road..

Speaking for myself, I would pass by a unit with a residential john in favor of the standard plastic deal.

[Old-Biscuit]

Who's making the Premier Elite 5th Wheel??

One time I contemplated putting in a residential chain toilet (overhead tank in cabinet) Shut-off valve on supply. Turn it off and drain tank for travel.

But didn't have center line to wall clearance for bowl.