cancel
Showing results forย 
Search instead forย 
Did you mean:ย 

instant water heater vs. conventional tank heater questions

rfuerst911sc
Explorer
Explorer
I am restoring an old camper which has a conventional LP powered 6 gallon water heater. I have no idea if it works but visually it looks good/clean with no obvious damage. But storage space is a premium commodity and I was wondering about an RV version of an " instant on " water heater ? By replacing the 6 gallon with an instant on I would gain considerable storage space and possibly more efficient water heating. So are any of you currently using a instant on water heater ? Are you happy with the performance ? Are there specific brands that are better than others ? Hot water would be plumbed to kitchen sink, bathroom sink and indoor shower if that matters. I would stay with LP fired. Any advice is appreciated.
4 REPLIES 4

WoodGlue
Explorer
Explorer
I don't think you'd be gaining much usable space by installing a tankless water heater and as the poster above me stated, RV usage and tankless applications aren't really ideal.

WoodGlue
2002 Land Rover Discovery II
2014 Lance 1685 - Loaded - 4 Seasons - Solar - 2 AGM's
When Hell Freezes Over - I'll Camp There Too!
Lance Travel Trailer Info - Lance 1685 Travel Trailer - Lance 1575 Trailer

Golden_HVAC
Explorer
Explorer
Hi,

Because of the varying needs of water volume and pressure in a RV, they are not good canidates for tankless water heaters.

Also I heard that one tankless water heater fits in the space of a 10 gallon tank type opening, and depth, so you will actually need more space to install that one.

Yes I have heard of another brand that is supposed to come out, with good variable gas burner, and better than average electronic controls, that will replace and fit in the space of a 6 gallon heater. Key features are a burner with up to 60,000 Btu's and three or more temperature sensors, along with water volume measurements. With three sensors, inlet water, mid way through the heat exchanger temp, and outlet temp, the computer that controls the gas valve can react quickly, and adjust the gas flow to keep the outlet temperature stable, despite changes in water volume or inlet water temp that will change the output temp - sometimes drastically.

The problems with a tankless is if the water volume falls below a certain amount, it can overheat and shut off, leaing to first scalding the person in the shower with 135F water then suddenly changing to 65F water. Some new heaters have the computer controls to try and prevent this, but some are not such good quality.

To extend my shower length, I use hot water to fill my fresh water tank. Once around 80F, I have a long and hot shower, even in the middle of winter.

Fred.
Money can't buy happiness but somehow it's more comfortable to cry in a

Porsche or Country Coach!



If there's a WILL, I want to be in it!



I havn't been everywhere, but it's on my list.

Kangen.com Alkaline water

Escapees.com

rfuerst911sc
Explorer
Explorer
gbopp thanks for the links, looks like I'll test the tank that I have an either use it or replace it with a similar version.