Did I dodge a bullet?

[Boxerslave]

Kids slept in tt over Xmas. Winterized of course. Turned on water heater instead of lights by accident and I caught it today when I got the bedding. Removed access cover to check the element and the tank was hot, no water in it. Do I consider myself extremely lucky or do I change element anyway?

[willi4nd]

As inexpensive as most elements are it wouldnt hurt to just replace it since it is winterized

[jmtandem]

Some hot water heaters never fully drain when removing the sacrifical rod. It is designed for the situation you described. Refill with water and try the element. If it heats you should be good.

[beemerphile1]

Boxerslave wrote:
Kids slept in tt over Xmas. Winterized of course. Turned on water heater instead of lights by accident and I caught it today when I got the bedding. Removed access cover to check the element and the tank was hot, no water in it. Do I consider myself extremely lucky or do I change element anyway?

If the tank was hot it proves the heating element is not burned out so yes, you dodged the bullet.

[gbopp]

wannavolunteerFT wrote:
So now, they get the house and I go out and have some privacy from all the visitors and sleep through the night even if the baby doesn't.

:C :C

[Old-Biscuit]

Boxerslave wrote:
Excellent point OB. Propane was on for furnace and I cannot remember if one or both switches were on ( one for AC other for gas and both side by side) Heater is an atwood and going by my track record I would bet the element fried and the gas warmed the tank.

New electric element and you should be good to go.

[Alabama_Jim]

I agree with nineoaks.

[Boxerslave]

Excellent point OB. Propane was on for furnace and I cannot remember if one or both switches were on ( one for AC other for gas and both side by side) Heater is an atwood and going by my track record I would bet the element fried and the gas warmed the tank.

[wannavolunteerF]

Boxerslave, When my kids come to visit, I stay in trailer and let them have the house. Had a similar incident, except kids left water heater on when they left. Thank goodness, it wasn't cold enough that we had no water in it. I also discovered they didn't realize they needed to open vent and turn on fan to release extra moisture when they showered.

So now, they get the house and I go out and have some privacy from all the visitors and sleep through the night even if the baby doesn't.

[Old-Biscuit]

Electric element turned on.......element will be burnt out due to lack of water
Propane turn on.......OK as far as propane burner BUT


What brand of water heater?

Atwood..........probably OK as tank is aluminum and t-stat would shut down when temp was reached. Tank can take the temp as long as it is allowed to cool before filling with water

Suburban......Maybe? Tank is steel but is glass lined. T-stat would shut down when temp was reached but glass lining may have cracked from the direct heating.

Fill it.......run it then if heats OK drain it and check for any 'debris' if Suburban

[Boxerslave]

Nineoaks Good advice, below freezing now, so I will try that later. Next time I will try to be smart enough to trip breaker before sleepovers.

[nineoaks2004]

Only way to know is turn off, let it cool, then fill with water and see if it heats ok and shuts off. If so you are lucky..

[naturist]

You may have dodged a bullet in the sense that the trailer didn't burn down. It is, however, likely that you damaged the water heater.