I rather wonder about this statement:
Instead of tediously starting and tending to a fire, I was able to purchase firewood at the general store. All I had to do was light it using some complimentary matches, and I was ready to make my meals.
Umm, aren't you still starting and tending the fire? Most campgrounds sell firewood and I don't think bringing a book of matches or a lighter is that difficult.
I can see it being an option for folks with the money wanting an "experience" just like resorts, spas, etc offer. But I think some of the "pros" listed are just trivial (wow, they put the toiletries in matching amber bottles). And for $175-475 per night, I'd like to think they offer more than microwaveable meals.