I am looking for opinions for a new porcelain toilet. 2 years ago I replaced my crappy toilet with a Dometic 310 porcelain toilet. First year the valve failed and cost me $30. to replace it. This weekend the foot valve stuck and flooded bath room , thank goodness it was clean water. The foot pedal was constantly sticking over the last several months. I am always cleaning the bottom slide valve and gasket and I am tired of messing with this thing. I am done with this POS toilet. The cheap plastic toilet I had in it worked better than this garbage thing. .Thanks for any input.

I am operating with a Thetford Aqua-Magic® Style II. I full time and I'm on unit #4. The first three failed in various ways from the water valve, foot flush mechanism, etc. Each time warranty covered it so I'm not out any money, but I am convinced of one thing. RV toilets aren't designed for full time use. The components just won't hold up. When this one fails I'll just buy another one and chuck this one in the trash. Changing the water valve involves messing with the foot flush and vice versa and if you change one you screw up the other. IMHONot worth changing parts. I just wish someone would make a quality unit.

We have the same toilet as edatlanta...it's our third. After replacing virtually every moving part on the last toilet, I have decided that from now on I will just replace the entire toilet when an issue arises!

1ofmany wrote:We have the same toilet as edatlanta...it's our third. After replacing virtually every moving part on the last toilet, I have decided that from now on I will just replace the entire toilet when an issue arises!For the price and less hassle factor - X2

Buy a theford bravura toilet it will be your last one

Everybody I know that has had the POS Thetford Aqua-Magic fail and that is ALOT of us! has replaced it with the Dometic 310 or 320 and have been very happy with them so I am surprised Your Dometic "crapped"out on ya,I installed a Dometic 310 on my 2012 and my 2015 and both have been reliable

New toilet for my fiver | Good Sam Community

14 Replies

newman_fulltime
Explorer II
May 31, 2016
Buy a theford bravura toilet it will be your last one
edatlanta
Explorer II
May 31, 2016
1ofmany wrote:
We have the same toilet as edatlanta...it's our third. After replacing virtually every moving part on the last toilet, I have decided that from now on I will just replace the entire toilet when an issue arises!

For the price and less hassle factor - X2
1ofmany
Explorer
May 31, 2016
We have the same toilet as edatlanta...it's our third. After replacing virtually every moving part on the last toilet, I have decided that from now on I will just replace the entire toilet when an issue arises!
edatlanta
Explorer II
May 31, 2016
I am operating with a Thetford Aqua-Magic® Style II. I full time and I'm on unit #4. The first three failed in various ways from the water valve, foot flush mechanism, etc. Each time warranty covered it so I'm not out any money, but I am convinced of one thing. RV toilets aren't designed for full time use. The components just won't hold up. When this one fails I'll just buy another one and chuck this one in the trash. Changing the water valve involves messing with the foot flush and vice versa and if you change one you screw up the other. IMHO

Not worth changing parts. I just wish someone would make a quality unit.

Forum Discussion

New toilet for my fiver

14 Replies

About Fifth Wheel Group

Related Content

Switching toilets

Wanting a Bidet for my Thedford toilet.

toilet

Best Fiver these days

Truck Shopping for Fiver