Forum Discussion

dshizzel's avatar
dshizzel
Explorer
Sep 13, 2014

Retiring 2015 - 5'er Advice/Experience Solicited

We're going to pull the trigger next year. We're paying off the S&B and keeping it as a home base. Will make 2-3 trips a year each with a 2-4 month duration.

We've had 2 5'ers and kinda know the ropes. First was a 27' Forest River WildWood - had lots of warranty problems with it. Put a bad taste in our mouths about FR, but I understand they're a different company than they were in the late 90's.

2nd was a 2001 31BWFS Sunnybrook which was trouble free and a joy to own.

Now, the truck is my domain, and I get complete control over that. But, the 5'er is DW's. I have veto power, but here's what we're looking at:

DW really wants a Big Country or Big Horn. Her main criteria are w/d prep, generally 4 seasons, fireplace (I know...), TV on opposite side as recliners (not in the back or front).

King bed is optional - we can do with queen or king. The trailer needs to be big enough to not get bad cabin fever if there's bad weather and we have 2 medium size dogs (60-70 lbs). I'd really like auto-level system, but I can live without it. So, we're probably looking at 38-40ft in length.

I like Heartland's all-in-one docking station for water, power, tanks, and cable/satellite.

I feel we will want to keep and use it a solid 10 years before we sell it and the S&B and settle in to a retirement community.

We intend to buy new and pay cash for both the TV and 5'er. Budget is right around $60k-65k for the 5'er.

Our so-far planned trips have us spanning the country at a leisurely pace and back home for about 1-2 months at a time for doctor visits and prescription refills and such.

So, with all that said, I'd like to hear from the community about whether the brand we're looking at is reliable and if the budget is realistic.

I know everyone is different and has different experience and needs. Thanks in advance for your contributions.

53 Replies

  • I wouldn't waste five minutes of my time planning ahead. You'll see.
  • I also know someone with a Cedar Creek, and they are still really happy with it.

    I am wondering if the SRW truck will be strong enough for your fifth wheel plans. The trucks do come with much higher GVWR than in 2000, however you are looking at fifth wheels that might be in the 3000 pound pin weight range.

    That said, you can always pick up a towing guide from the local dealers, and get to know the capabilities of the trucks.

    Good luck!

    Fred.
  • Were going on ten years with our Cedar Creek and other than routine upkeep has bees great. Looks nearly as good as in 2005 when we bought it. Start looking at used trailers in brands you want to see how they hold up several years down the road. IMHO floor plan is patamount as many many components come from only a couple suppliers. So differences are small