While cummins2014, and others on these forums, are happy with their Andersen hitch, they have the steel 4-point attaching Andersen.
I don't recall a failure picture of the 4-point att steel hitch?
I think the aluminum hitch would be a good option for many, if it fit the rail system, or best of all the pucks. The lateral forces that appeared to be the problem in the destroyed Ultimate hitch, likely would not have happened, if attached at 4 corner points. JMO
I will add, IMO, the puck attaching hitches are the future, best option. Anyone having the factory pucks should consider a hitch that fits them directly.
Jerry