Forum Discussion

sb201's avatar
sb201
Explorer
Jul 29, 2013

2008 Discovery or 2006 Mandalay

Can't Decide....buy a 2006 Mandalay with 15,000 miles on it or a 2008 Discovery with 15,000 miles. Like the paint on the Mandalay best but like the floorplan on the Discovery best. I have a 7 & 9 year old that figure into the decision also. I want to make sure I don't buy something that ends up costing time and money by being in the shop.
The Mandalay has 400hp and the Discovery has 350hp.
Any thoughts or considerations I should think about?
They are within $5,000 of each other.

Thanks! Scott
  • I go with newer, the better floor plan and the great service from Fleetwood.
  • I'm not super-familiar with the Fleetwood lineup, but I think the Mandalay might be a little higher up in terms of features, etc. However, 2 years newer levels the field, though the (probably) smaller engine in the Fleetwood is a concern. But I agree that floor plan outranks paint color any day.
  • Drive them both....the power is going to be a big difference I believe the 350hp in the discovery, being an 08' has the small but emission compliant (for new 08' regs) cummins ISB which is only 660 ft/lbs of torque, the mandalay will have at least 1150 ft/lbs and will be a huge difference in how they drive providing that the weights are similar.
  • I wish I had your problem. :C
    crimmps49 is correct. Get the floorplan that suits your lifestyle.
    Let us know what you decide.
    Enjoy your travels.
  • I'd go for the floorplan you like best. Paint is just something to look at, floor plans are what you have to live with.