Forum Discussion

jdmcleod's avatar
jdmcleod
Explorer
Jun 03, 2013

Help with new engine decision

My beloved 1992 Holiday Rambler Imperial with a Chevy 454 and 4l80E trans decided to blow its rod bearing on our trip home going up a hill (it's always seemed a bit underpowered on hills since I had it these past 5 years). Got towed into a car&truck garage, quoted labor time for R&R of the engine to be "a week and a half." This turns out to be $4200+ just for labor, not including the new engine, and any other parts that are needed. After I regained consciousness, I became resolved to find a better solution for my family.

My question is, how hard is it to do this yourself? Out the driver's side door, I imagine. What can I put back in that will have better power, or will a refreshed Chevy 454 be much more powerful than the one that died with 72,000 miles on it? Crate or Reman? It has TBI now, any changes there if I went with a newer Vortec? I believe the OEM is gen. V that was hobbled/underpowered for emissions sake. Need some advice, especially from those that have been here before. What is my best bang for the buck. I have time to work on it myself, just need to know how difficult it actually is. My ultimate goal is to pull a grade without the engine dancing up and the speed dogging back to 45-50 mph on medium sized hills. GM HT502 looks nice, but big $ and expensive on premium gas. Want to do it right, but economically as well. (I expect the "buy a diesel pusher" comments, but that's not in the cards yet.)
  • Unless you put a supercharger on that 454 you're not gonna be pulling hills like you want. Doing it yourself is doable if you have experience in this sort of thing. I've pulled and installed several engines in my lifetime but never in a motor home....don't think I would try it.

    Ron
  • We put in a new crated 454 chevy engine in a 1991 fleetwood pace arrow, it was $9980. Agains my thoughts, and it didn't help the power also it did not help the trade in value. We did buy the DP, it doesn't even start to slow down on the large hills, and will actually pass a semi.