TreeSeeker - Neither.
Do the five to four conversion.
Mancini, Summit, or MoParts. Anything less than $50USD is likely lower quality and questionable durability and reliability.
If you're determined to go aftermarket, BWD brand is currently the ONLY one I'd trust ... and I don't like redoing repair jobs, especially if it's because I cut costs/corners and wound up using substandard parts.
CarQuest (which has been bought out by a national chain) BWD part number is CBE14, described as "Premium Quality." Another BWD part number is CBE14P, described as "OE Style." List prices are $62.09 and $62.99, respectively. With the discount for my commercial account, my cost is $58.99 and $56.99, respectively.
You may be able to get close to or match that price ... they've been screwing with my discount lately.
