Forum Discussion

OktsCamp's avatar
OktsCamp
Explorer
Feb 11, 2015

Looking for advice....used vs new

Having some discussion with the Mrs, and now some of my own internal "struggles" if you will on a potential purchase we have made (of course its only on "hold" until I get get it driven etc.), but here is my dilemma....

I found what I believe to be a good deal on a used machine (2008) but it is 7 years old. While I will purchase extended warranty to cover appliances etc., even power train, it is still 7 years old. It certainly does not look it mind you, near new if you ask me, but on paper...its 7 years old. So in 5 years, what's it going to be worth, now its 12 years old, assume things will all still be working, but has it lost a ton of value.

She thinks I should buy new, trouble is, to get what we want new, is like another $40-50K. While I realize it has "new" warranty, powertrain etc., it will still depreciate significantly. If I want to spend around the same money, or even a bit more going from used to new, I frankly get a much lower quality unit.

So I am torn....do I spend $70K on a 2008 vs 100K on a "new" machine, that is NO where near the same quality...its just new. I really only need this machine to last us 5-7 years, at which time we plan to upgrade to the "retirement" version if you will.

I am sure I am not the only one to ask himself this question. I am confidnet that spending the money on the used as I say is good value, and in 5 years it will still have some value, mind you, not nearly as high as it is today of course.

thanks for reading.

42 Replies

  • The average RV user puts around 5000 miles per YEAR on their coach. That means that IF you are average, you may put 25,000 to 35,000 miles on in the next 5-7 years. Do you think the used 2008 RV will make it another 25-35,000 miles, with minimal care? Probably
    Now if you bought a new coach, what do you think it will be worth in 5-7 years with 25-35,000 miles?
    Do the math and then see if it is really important to drive a new RV vrs a used RV that will probably suit your needs just fine.
    Most of us buy our RV's with zero expectation of getting anything back when we sell it. It is all about the journey and pleasure that we get from it. I used the example before of a trip the wife and I took down to Machu Picchu, Peru for several weeks. For us it was a fantastic trip and the thousands that we spent was gone. There was no recovery or trade-in value for that trip and we would do it again in a heartbeat.