Forum Discussion

Mondooker's avatar
Mondooker
Explorer
Feb 13, 2016

My Motorhome Selections

I've listed information below about the motorhomes I'm interested in and have listed them in no special order. They are all bath and a half and all have an MSRP within $10,000.00 of each other. With the exception of the Thor Miramar with a shorter WB but same quality level as the Challenger.

I know with automobiles the best ride comes from weight and wheelbase and would guess the same is true of motorhomes. The Forest River Georgetown XL and the two Newmar's have 26,000 chassis and the Newmar 3953 has a Wheel Base of 260.

Since they all have the same engine. Will the motorhomes with the bigger chassis suffer in power because of the added weight?

I'd also like to know if you have a preference on what side of the coach the bedroom slide is on and why?

I'd love to hear from you and especially those who currently have or has had one of theses coaches?

Thank you all

Forest River Georgetown XL 360DS - 37.6L - 242WB - 26,000 CH - 10 Gal HW - 5.5 Gen - $181M
Newmar Canyon Star 3710 - 38L - 242 WB - 26,000CH - 10 Gal HW - 10 Gen - $185M
Newmar Canyon Star 3953 - 40L - 260 WB - 26,000CH - 10 Gal HW - 5.5 Gen - $189M
Thor Challenger 37LX - 38.1L - 252WB - 22,000CH - 6 Gal HW - 7 Gen - $178M
Thor Miramar 34.1 - 35.10L - 242 WB - 22,000CH - 6 gal HW - 7 Gen - $156M
Tiffin Allegro 36LA - 37.6L - 252 WB - 24,000CH - 10 gal HW - 7 Gen - $171M
Class A
  • smlranger's avatar
    smlranger
    Explorer
    Feb 13, 2016
    Agree with Dutch Star Don. Regardless of which coach you choose, make sure you evaluate its livability beforehand. Some of the newer floor plans leave little room to walk to the back of the coach when the slides are in, just as an example. How you plan to use it, how much you plan to drive it, etc. should factor into your decision.

    All the manufacturers have quality control issues, some more than others. However, some seem to do a much better job of dealing with the issues. While none of us has objective data to offer, opinions can be offered. IMO, Newmar and Tiffin would be higher on my list than the others you listed.
  • DSDP_Don's avatar
    DSDP_Don
    Explorer
    Feb 13, 2016
    "Mondooker"......I can't help you with your choice because it's all about your budget, what's acceptable quality to you and the floorplan you like. My sister and BIL just went shopping for a new Class A gasser and looked at similar coaches. They were all ready to sign on the dotted line with Tiffin, when my long legged BIL had them close the big slide and found he didn't fit in the front seat with the slide in. Make sure you check simple things like the above.
  • Bumpyroad's avatar
    Bumpyroad
    Explorer
    Feb 13, 2016
    Newmar or Tiffin. if any have a non -fiberglass roof, get the other one.
    bumpy

About Motorhome Group

38,707 PostsLatest Activity: Feb 20, 2025