Forum Discussion

Geocritter's avatar
Geocritter
Explorer
Jul 02, 2013

NAPA and Monroe shock absorbers

I have a question about shock absorbers. My RV, a 1994 33’ Holiday Rambler Vacationer, came standard with Bilstein shocks, that was 58K ago. I’ve only driven the RV a short ways since I bought it in April, however that short way was on I-35 while a 30-35 mph cross wind was hammering me. The rig drove surprisingly well, however it obviously needs shocks (riding Flipper comes to mind). When I priced out the Bilsteins all I could think was YIKES! I’m a very pragmatic guy and am not really bothered that much by a harsh ride (it must be that amazingly sturdy and durable body that God blessed me with) so I decided to look into shocks that were a bit cheaper, hopefully quite a bit cheaper. I went to NAPA but they didn’t have a listing for my rig and weren’t certain how to look up shocks for it. The clerk suggested that I bring a front and rear shock in so that they might do a side-by-side comparison. Would anyone out there know of a way to look up the NAPA or perhaps Monroe shocks without having to make a physical side-by-side comparison.

And please, remember, I’m the guy who never slows down for speed bumps, who ran his 1991 Dodge Caravan work car 256K miles with the original shocks. I’m just not a Princess and the Pea kind of guy, particularly if I can get an adequate ride and save a pile of $$$$ to boot. I apologize but the truth is, rhapsodizing endlessly about Bilstein’s and Koni’s is likely to fall on deaf ears.

Steve

29 Replies

  • if your going for Monroes...save your time and labor...they don't last and every Monroe I have ever used on cars and pickups didn't do much for dampening.
    Id take worn out Bilsteins over new Monroes any day
  • Don't think I would use that NAPA for anything.

    Give Amazon a look. Clicky.

    Make sure you use your specs and not the one in the link. They should be the same, but.....
  • GoPackGo wrote:
    I just bought Bilsteins for my F-350 and they came with a lifetime warranty. So you might want to contact Bilstein and ask if yours have the same warranty.


    Good advice. However, most lifetime warantees are only for the original owner. Never hurts to try.

    Ray
  • Stengel Bros is an excellent source for Monroe RV Magnums. If you desire other brands try shock warehouse. Forget NAPA, most of their counter personnel have their heads stuck where the sun never shines.
  • I just bought Bilsteins for my F-350 and they came with a lifetime warranty. So you might want to contact Bilstein and ask if yours have the same warranty.
  • ^^^ what ScottG said

    The outside of the shock has little bearing on the internal valving, which has to account for things like spring rate, vehicle weight, and myriad other factors.
  • Geocritter, go to stengelbros.com....they carry the Monroe RV Gas Magnum shocks you're looking for. I had a 35' P32 chassis that came with Bilsteins, I switched out to the Monroes for a MUCH smoother ride.
  • I'd be hesitant to buy shocks that were just matched up externally. The valving for a heavy rig like yours may be very different from other applications that the unknown shock fits.
    The Bilsteins are very good for porpoising - at least when they're newer.
    No matter what I would get shocks that are specifically for your chassis even if that means you have to get the more expensive Bils again (which are my personal favorite).
    Good lick,
    Scott