Forum Discussion

lordnorth's avatar
lordnorth
Explorer
Aug 23, 2014

Rambler Admiral vs Coachmen Mirada -- Advice

Looking for a Class A Bunkhouse...

Provided the price, condition, mileage, and layout were roughly equal, if you were given the following choice, which would you take:

2007 Holiday Rambler Admiral 34SBD

2011 Coachmen Mirada 34BH

Would you elaborate why you would make that choice?

30 Replies

  • lordnorth wrote:
    Interestingly enough... Here is what the NADA Guide has to say about value (I put them in as simply base price, no options, actual mileage):

    One is:
    Low Retail $64,334 Average Retail $77,511

    Other:
    Low Retail $55,982 Average Retail $67,454

    Guess which is which?

    According to NADA, the Coachmen has the higher value than the HR...

    Interesting... What are your thoughts on that?


    4 years newer probably the reason. not overall quality. lipstick on a pig.
    bumpy
  • Interestingly enough... Here is what the NADA Guide has to say about value (I put them in as simply base price, no options, actual mileage):

    One is:
    Low Retail $64,334 Average Retail $77,511

    Other:
    Low Retail $55,982 Average Retail $67,454

    Guess which is which?

    According to NADA, the Coachmen has the higher value than the HR...

    Interesting... What are your thoughts on that?
  • HR. My dad, brother and I all have 99-02 endeavor DP's and love them. My dad has owned his the longest, about 4 years. He absolutely loves the quality of his unit. My brother and I can say the same about ours. Just a great piece of machinery.
  • Okay... HR by a long shot.

    Now.... Why HR?

    (No offense.. but please give me something other than "its a better Motorhome" if you would.)

    I'm not saying that I don't agree with you... I am asking what, in your opinion, makes the HR a better choice.