Mine was maintained and failed after 5 years (water was leaking through the membrane). I now have a
New Roof and no more worries about rubber or caulking and it is so much quieter. I am hearing impaired and I can now actually hear the TV when it is raining.
I would replace a brand new rubber roof with this product and just consider it part of the purchase price.
At the same time I got rid of the crank up TV antenna which was a pain and I never used it anyway. And it leaked through the antenna on to my bed a couple of times. It is now in the trash somewhere.