My rubber roof is also 15 years old and fine. Big problem with roofs (All kinds) is the seams. Any cracks or bad looking areas should be looked after. I use Dicor lap sealant. Others like other products but the dicor stays some what soft and can be removed with a plastic putty knife if a small area needs replacing. And a small area will blend in with the old seam. Remember the roof is a large flat area that is working and twisting all the time so keep an eye on all the seams.. In all truth I think and rubber roofs are the best after spending a couple weeks helping a friend replace much of his fiber glass roof. There is no real fix it once and forget it product no matter what others say. I am not saying Dicor is the best just the easiest to work with over the years..